As a Lawyer, You Sent the Judge In?

Chapter 239 Have a strong tendency? Come on, let me take a look

 Time goes very quickly.…

 It’s court time.

Originally, some of Xiao Haibo’s colleagues, partners and some friends were coming to Chongqing to take a look at the court hearing.

　　It means to come over and cheer up your friends, and at the same time, you also tacitly oppose the unfair judicial situation such as re-marketing.

but.…

This time the court hearing is still a live broadcast, a public hearing, and the relevant content of the trial can be watched online.

 Zhang Yuan, as Xiao Haibo’s assistant lawyer, persuaded these lawyer friends of Xiao Haibo.

 At the same time, he expressed that this was also what Xiao Haibo meant, and that was why the others did not insist on participating in the trial.

 It’s court time.

 At ten o'clock in the morning, the court session begins on time.

 All parties are seated.

Ma Qiao stood in front of the presiding judge's seat, sorting out relevant litigation materials.

 About this case.

 In response to Xiao Haibo’s perjury.

On the eve of the trial, someone greeted him and told him what the sentence should be in this trial, and even told him the sentence.

Ma Qiao, who was sitting on the presiding judge's seat, felt helpless. He didn't want to do what the other party said, but the reality was that he had no choice.

I can only say to take it step by step and see what happens in the court hearing.

Thinking of this, Ma Qiao couldn't help but sigh silently in his heart.

 “Let’s see the specific plea in the court hearing!”

Ma Qiao thought silently in his heart.

Although I said hello...but this case...

Ma Qiao did not think any further. He looked around the court scene and continued:

 “The court is now in session!”

  “Cause of this case:”

“The public prosecution against the defendant Xiao Haibo for teaching and inducing his client Xia Guangming to commit perjury in the case against Wanli Co., Ltd. will be held in court.”

 The gavel struck.

“Now please state the facts, relevant evidence and legal basis:”

 “A good judge.”

After getting the approval from the presiding judge, the prosecutor Shi Xiujie, as the prosecutor this time, nodded and responded.

 In this case, for the prosecutor Shi Xiujie, the trial came with a mission.

However, this task is relatively simple.

As the prosecutor of this case, he knows very well whether Xiao Haibo has committed perjury and whether it constitutes perjury.

 But it’s clear…it should be prosecuted, or it needs to be prosecuted.

 The rest has nothing to do with him.

He only needs to state the relevant content in this court hearing.

Shi Xiujie continued to speak:

“After our verification, in this case, the defendant Xiao Haibo deliberately guided and misled the party Xia Guangming in the case against Wanli Co., Ltd., and was suspected of inducement and guidance.”

“According to the provisions of the Criminal Law Regulations, the relevant understanding and application of Article 305 of the crime of perjury and Article 306 of the crime of destroying evidence, fabricating evidence, and obstructing testimony by a defender or agent ad litem.”

“Xiao Haibo has violated perjury, fabricating evidence and obstructing testimony in the criminal law.”

“Based on the above, we apply for a judgment on Xiao Haibo.”

“The sentence is: two years’ imprisonment.”

“Presiding judge, we have finished our statement.”

Facing prosecutor Shi Xiujie’s statement, Su Bai’s eyes fell on the presiding judge’s seat.

ˆBased on Xiao Haibo’s experience and the outrageousness of this case.

What to say about this court proceeding...

 It was originally a case of territorial protection.

 Wanli Co., Ltd. is topped by the heavily marketed Wanli Group.

 The court definitely has a certain tendency in court hearings.

Perhaps they have already said hello, and some outrageous courts have already written judgments before the court session.

This kind of presiding judge can be said to have completed his work prematurely.

 I just hope that today’s court hearing will not encounter a situation where the judgment is written in advance.

According to Su Bai's estimation, Xiao Haibo was far from committing perjury in this trial.

If the presiding judge relies on this tendency to impose a sentence, then I'm sorry.

 See the supervision and review department.

 Can’t see you?

 It doesn’t matter, change the jurisdiction of the court.

At most it will take some time, but it will definitely send the person to the supervision department to have a big meal.

 In court trials, the most important thing is the judge’s opinion.

 At present, the specific circumstances of the trial have not yet begun, and arguments still need to continue.

.

 ….

 At the seat of the presiding judge.

After listening to the prosecutor’s statement, Ma Qiao glanced at the litigation materials and spoke slowly:

“Do the defendant’s parties and the defendant’s attorney need to make statements?”

 “There is a chief judge.”

Su Bai nodded and stated: "Presiding judge, we think the prosecutor's accusation is unreasonable."

“I would like to ask what is the basis for the prosecutor to accuse our client of engaging in inducement?”

“The prosecutor did not state clearly the most important point.”

“I would like to ask the prosecutor to clarify this point.”

 The gavel struck.

Presiding judge Ma Qiao looked at Shi Xiujie: "Please elaborate on the questions raised by the lawyer entrusted by the defendant."

"OK."

Shi Xiujie nodded in agreement. This problem was not a problem for him.

 After responding to the presiding judge, he continued:

 “Before responding to the defendant’s litigation lawyer’s questions.”

“I would like to ask the defendant a few questions.”

"OK."

Facing the application made by the prosecutor, Xiao Haibo nodded and accepted.

"Thank you for your cooperation, but based on the current court situation, I would like to ask the defendant to state the key points in your representation of Xia Guangming's case."

 “What does the key content refer to?”

Shi Xiujie asked and further explained.

“Refers to the key points in your behavior that induce suspicion.”

“But I don’t think I am suspected of inducing, there is no critical point.

I don’t understand why the prosecutor asked me such a question, but regarding this point, prosecutor, it’s not that I can’t answer your question, it’s that I can’t answer your question. "

Although Xiao Haibo is not a criminal lawyer, the question asked by the other party was obviously not right, so he directly responded.

Facing Xiao Haibo's reply, Shi Xiujie smiled, feeling a little uncomfortable.

 But he didn’t show too much and continued to speak.

"The defendant's reply is that there is no suspicion of inducement, but based on your client's statement and accusation at the time." "Your client at the time, Xia Guangming, accused you of telling him that you must remain silent during the trial. You can answer those who should answer, but don’t answer those who shouldn’t, right?”

 “Yes, but isn’t this inductive?”

Xiao Haibo asked rhetorically.

"This sentence is not instructive, but you once proposed that your client Xia Guangming should not speak when answering the questions of the trial, and leave all the power to you.

why is that?

 During the trial at that time, when the presiding judge asked whether your client and the manager of Wanli Co., Ltd. knew each other, did you answer that you didn’t? "

Xiao Haibo frowned slightly: "I don't know what the prosecutor has been emphasizing, or I don't understand why the prosecutor asked such uncertain questions."

“I will answer the prosecutor’s first question first, because this case is under special agency authority, which means that I can make statements, withdraw the case, etc. on behalf of our client.”

"Based on this, I told my client not to say too much at the trial, okay?"

“Besides, did Xia Guangming really say that he doesn’t know the manager of Wanli Co., Ltd.?”

“Xia Guangming’s statement was that he was not familiar with the manager of Wanli Co., Ltd., but he knew him. The relationship between the two was not between friends, but between customers.”

"I would like to ask the prosecutor to understand this before questioning me. Otherwise, it will appear that the prosecutor's questions are not of any standard and he will seduce me."

"If the prosecutor questions me like this again, can I also understand that the prosecutor is suspected of seducing me into perjury during the process of questioning me?"

 Xiao Haibo is a civil lawyer, but he understands the basic litigation process and procedures.

 Besides, it’s not like civil lawyers don’t understand criminal matters at all.

ˆBasic logical processing capabilities still exist.

Facing the prosecutor’s repeated blind questions, Xiao Haibo responded directly with one sentence.

 At the prosecutor's seat.

Shi Xiujie's face was obviously red and swollen for a while.

But soon, his mood calmed down.

It feels good to confront him now, but later the regret will show up when the verdict is handed down.

 Under this situation and after greetings, there are no other problems in this case.

 The Xiao Haibo in front of me should be sentenced or sentenced!

Thinking of this, Shi Xiujie's anger dissipated and he responded to Xiao Haibo's question with a smile.

“But after the prosecutor’s understanding, your client Xia Guangming not only knew the manager of Wanli Co., Ltd., but also they were good friends.”

“According to Xia Guangming, this lawsuit was originally an ordinary loan relationship, but the way you sued was Wanli Co., Ltd.’s illegal fund-raising. Do you know this?”

 Xiao Haibo:.…

  ? ? ?

 Ordinary loan relationship?

do you know?

 What the hell!

Xiao Haibo frowned slightly, and the tone of his statement began to speed up:

“According to the information I learned and investigated at the time, Wanli Co., Ltd. was indeed conducting illegal fund-raising, rather than an ordinary lending relationship.”

“In this lawsuit that I represented Xia Guangming, based on the evidence at the time, there was no problem in using illegal fund-raising to prosecute.”

“I don’t know whether Xia Guangming and the manager of Wanli Co., Ltd. were involved in loans at the time, but what Xia Guangming and I stated at that time was—”

"Wanli Co., Ltd. sold a financial product, saying it was a good product within the group. Xia Guangming purchased it. The manager of Wanli Co., Ltd. promised before purchasing the product that the principal and interest would be returned after a certain period of time. "

“This financial product is not distributed through legal means by the state.”

“Isn’t this illegal fund-raising?”

"Xia Guangming at that time issued me the purchase materials, including the receipt that was retained at the time of purchase."

“Private lending should be an IOU, rather than giving related purchase notes.”

“There is an essential difference between illegal fund-raising and lending.”

As a first-class civil litigation lawyer, when Shi Xiujie raised relevant issues on the prosecutor’s side, Xiao Haibo immediately refuted it.

 And the rebuttal was quite forceful.

Su Bai frowned slightly after listening to prosecutor Shi Xiujie's inquiry and statement.

Aren't you trying to put something dirty on Xiao Haibo?

 Private lending and illegal fund-raising must be clearly distinguished!

 In response to this point, even Xia Guangming changed his confession and believed that the two of them were in a loan-lending relationship between friends.

  But in fact there is still a relationship between illegal fund-raising.

 At least in Xiao Haibo’s subjective opinion and relevant evidence, it is still illegal fund-raising.

Xia Guangming's single confession cannot establish the facts, it can only prove that Xia Guangming perjured himself.

Furthermore, it is impossible for the court to only listen to Xia Guangming’s single confession to make a judgment.

Certification must be based on facts and evidence from all aspects. Xia Guangming just changed his confession without any strong evidence to prove his confession. What's the use?

Does the court really dare to make a judgment based on a single confession?

Definitely not!

If this case is judged based on only one confession, it will set a precedent in Su Bai's knowledge.

　　If you don’t send this group of people in together, it will be a disgrace to the legal knowledge he has learned.

so.

This point of view cannot prove that Xiao Haibo is suspected of perjury.

Su Bai didn't know the meaning of Shi Xiujie's question. The current prosecutor was completely beaten by Xiao Haibo.

Su Bai raised his hand and said: "Presiding judge, the questions asked by the prosecutor have exceeded the relevant content of this trial."

“I apply to stop the prosecution from continuing to conduct questions and answers about our client.”

 At the trial bench, Ma Qiao frowned slightly when facing Su Bai's application.

He pretended not to hear anything, and at this time, Shi Xiujie continued to prepare for questioning.

Su Baique interrupted him and spoke directly: "The prosecutor's inquiry just now has exceeded the specific content of this trial."

“It is inconsistent with the charges against us and is aimed at irrelevant issues raised by the prosecutor.”

“According to the relevant provisions of the Criminal Procedure Law, we have the right to refuse to answer.”

Su Bai opened his mouth to conduct a related trial, but couldn't the presiding judge hear him?

 If you can’t hear it, it doesn’t matter. I will tell my client what I said.

 As long as the questions you raise are not relevant to this court hearing, Xiao Haibo can refuse to answer. Not answering your questions is equivalent to raising your questions in vain.

 If you don’t stop it, then if I don’t answer, that’s the end of it?

Xiao Haibo heard Su Bai's statement, smiled and nodded, indicating that he understood.

 As someone who has known Su Bai for so long, I know Su Bai’s style very well.

This implicit meaning is that there is no need to answer questions raised by the prosecutor and the presiding judge that have nothing to do with this trial and have nothing to do with the accusation of perjury against him...

Of course Shi Xiujie and Ma Qiao could understand the meaning of Su Bai's words.

Shi Xiujie glanced towards the presiding judge's seat.

 Exhale softly.

 What happens if I’m not allowed to ask?

 Can it still affect the final judgment of this trial?

Thinking of this, Shi Xiujie couldn't help but glance in Su Bai's direction.

Su Bai noticed Shi Xiujie's gaze, saw the general thoughts in Shi Xiujie's heart, and smiled.

Regional protection, right?

This trial has a strong tendency, right?

Even though he had a strong tendency, he really didn’t believe that the presiding judge would convict Xiao Haibo in this trial!



 Come, come, let me take a look.

PS: Please give me monthly votes~

 (End of this chapter)