Comprehensive View: Married to wife Zhao Mosheng, but she did not consummate the marriage

As a lawyer, Jiang Haochen of course knows that so many assets are involved, and it is impossible to deny that Xia Xiting is not a joint venture with Yao Yanxu just by relying on such a little evidence.

Jiang Haochen continued: "Presiding judge, the trial, just this chat record from many years ago is indeed not convincing. "

"But there is a problem with what lawyer Cheng said just now. That is, Ms. Xia and Mr. Yao were not in an ambiguous period at that time. "

Jiang Haochen looked at Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong again: "Ms. Miao, Ms. Li, what Ms. Xia liked back then should be the object of her extramarital affair, Mr. Ruan Qisheng~, right?"

"Yes. When she was in school, Xiting had a crush on Ruan Qisheng, and even the two of them were together for more than half a year. "

Due to Ruan Qisheng's excellent grades and full scholarships from prestigious foreign schools, with the opportunity to go abroad, the two broke up with each other by default. "

Li Weitong followed Miao Qinghe's words and added: "After graduation, although Xiting is single, Xiting should not have liked Yao Yanxu, at that time, Yao Yanxu simply liked Xiting. "

Xiting knew that Yao Yanxu liked herself, but Yao Yanxu had a good personality and was very good to her, so she treated Yao Yanxu as a good friend. "

"In today's parlance, it's a spare tire. "

Hearing this, Yao Yanxu's expression was ugly.

Yao Yanxu's expression was ugly, not because Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong said that he was a spare tire, but because Yao Yanxu really thought that Xia Xiting and himself were ambiguous at that time.

Especially when she is unemployed, Xia Xiting is also willing to lend money to start a business.

I always thought it was true love, but it turned out to be just a spare tire.

It turns out that the clown is himself.

Jiang Haochen looked at Xia Xiting: "Ms. Xia, do you agree with this statement?"

"I don't agree, I said this to Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong at the time, just because I was embarrassed to admit it. "

"After I broke up with Nguyen Qi Sheng, I was disheartened with him at the time. "

Jiang Haochen immediately asked, "Really, are you sure?"

Jiang Haochen specially asked Xia Xiting if she was sure, and Xia Xiting was a little hesitant.

Xia Xiting looked at Cheng Taihua, Cheng Taihua could only nod at Xia Xiting and let Xia Xiting give an affirmative answer.

Because if you don't give an affirmative answer at this time, it will definitely not work.

Otherwise, if you deny what you just said, you have to do it.

Xia Xiting replied to Jiang Haochen: "If I hadn't had a good impression of Yanxu at that time, how could I lend him money to start a business?"

Jiang Haochen immediately smiled: "Presiding judge, the trial, I will confirm it with Ms. Xia again in front of you." "

"Ms. Xia, please answer me again in front of the presiding judge and the trial. "

"Are you really frustrated with your ex-boyfriend, have a good impression of Mr. Yao, and are in an ambiguous period, so you gave the money to Mr. Yao and started a business together?"

Xia Xiting was very panicked, but she still replied stubbornly: "That's right." "

"Presiding Judge, at the trial, I found out that Ms. Xia is really a person who lies a lot. Let's take a look at the new evidence. "

"This chat log of mine is a chat between Ms. Xia and Mr. Ruan, who is having an extramarital affair. "

This chat record can not only prove that Ms. Xia did not like Mr. Yao and had no feelings for Mr. Ruan, but also can prove that the 20,000 yuan that Ms. Xia gave to Mr. Yao was a loan. "

Of course, this chat log was saved by Mr. Ruan's ex-girlfriend abroad in the form of a video. "

In addition, Mr. Ruan broke up with his girlfriend when Ms. Xia and Mr. Yao were in a divorce lawsuit. "

As she spoke, Zhou Ruoyao connected Jiang Haochen's mobile phone to the screen.

An original video shows it.

Zhou Ruoyao pulled the video to the required duration.

When she saw this chat record, Xia Xiting's expression sank.

I saw that the chat record was dated and it wasn't long before Xia Xiting lent the money to Yao Yanxu.

Here's what the chat is about.

[Ruan Qisheng]: [You lend money to Yao Yanxu, you won't like Yao Yanxu, right?]

[Xia Xiting]: [Of course I don't like Yao Yanxu anymore, what I like is you, and you don't know it, but you still study abroad. (Angry emoji)】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [I can't go abroad. If you don't like Yao Yanxu, you go and get the money back. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [Isn't this okay? 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Then aren't you afraid that I will be angry?]

[Xia Xiting]: [But I said that I would lend it to him, and now I take it back, I can't open my mouth.] 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Then I'm angry. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [Don't be angry. I'll find a chance when I get back. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [Why don't you speak?]

[Xia Xiting]: [Don't ignore me. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [I'll ask him to get it back in a few days, it's always okay, right?]

However, this is the time when Ruan Qisheng is obviously angry and does not reply to Xia Xiting.

Three days later, Xia Xiting sent a message to Ruan Qisheng, but still did not receive a reply.

On the fifth day.

[Xia Xiting]: [I have already asked Yao Yanxu to get the money back. 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [That's pretty much it. But are you sure you're not lying to me?]

[Xia Xiting]: [Of course I didn't lie to you, he and I have already cleared up, so don't be angry. 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Then you transfer the money, and I will keep it for you.] I'll give it back to you when you need it, lest you and I do superficial work. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [20,000 transfers. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [It's okay now, right?]

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Good, this is my baby. 】

Seeing this, Yao Yanxu clenched his fists, already angry.

Yao Yanxu said: "I remember, back then, you said that your grandmother was sick and paid 20,000 yuan from the account, which turned out to be Ruan Qisheng's garbage." "

Xia Xiting was speechless.

Cheng Taihua panicked at this time: "It's over, the situation is not good now." "

If it is really confirmed that this is a loan, it will directly become a headwind.

Jiang Haochen can find so much evidence, Cheng Taihua has no confidence to turn the headwind situation into a tailwind situation.

Jiang Haochen said again: "Presiding judge, the trial, I believe it can be determined from the chat records above, this is a loan, and Ms. Xia has already found an excuse to take it back." "

"Even if it was a shareholding at the beginning, and the 20,000 yuan was taken away at that time, Ms. Xia and Mr. Ruan said that they had cleared up with Mr. Yao, so it was considered a withdrawal of shares, right?"

"It's just that after Ms. Xia and our client were together, our client was always in love, so I didn't dwell on these things. "

Hearing Jiang Haochen say that he was in love, Yao Yanxu knew that Jiang Haochen was saving face for himself.

Because isn't that just licking a dog?

However, the most depressing thing is that he was Xia Xiting's licking dog, and Xia Xiting was Ruan Qisheng's licking dog.

Yao Yanxu felt too insulted.

Jiang Haochen continued to look at Xia Xiting: "Ms. Xia, can you say that my chat record is fake?"

"If you dare to say that it is fake, then do you dare to take out the chat history on your phone and compare it?"

However, how dare Xia Xiting?

Xia Xiting could only look at Cheng Taihua for help.

Cheng Taihua was helpless.

In this chat record, Xia Xiting's chat attitude is the same as licking a dog.

If you want to say that this is not like Ruan Qisheng, it is unreasonable.

Even if Cheng Taihua continued to insist that Xia Xiting liked Yao Yanxu at this time, the presiding judge and the court would not believe it.

The most important thing is that, as Jiang Haochen said, if you get 20,000 yuan back, then even if you buy shares, it is equivalent to withdrawing shares.

Then these shares are pre-marital property, and at most the appreciation after marriage is calculated.

That's pretty damn.

Cheng Taihua didn't expect that such a small detail could be turned over by Jiang Haochen against the wind.

The presiding judge looked at Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting: "Does the defendant have anything to explain?"

Seeing that Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting did not speak, the presiding judge said again: "If the defendant has nothing to say, then this court will adopt this statement." "

Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting were silent again, and the presiding judge said: "Plaintiff, this testimony will be accepted by this court." "

"Do you have anything else to add?"

"Absolutely. "

Jiang Haochen smiled faintly, knowing that he had succeeded for the most part.

"If the pre-marital property part is clear, and all the equity of the factory belongs to our agent, then the property of the husband and wife only covers the part of the growth in the five years of marriage, plus cash, real estate, and some stocks invested, a total of more than 5 billion, I will count it as 5 billion. "

"The presiding judge, the trial, and in fact, a considerable amount of property was transferred by Ms. Xia. "

"Let's talk about Ms. Xia's transfer to Mr. Ruan first. "

"This chat record is all in this chat record, and every time Ms. Xia transfers money to Mr. Ruan, she notifies Mr. Ruan. "

"I counted the chat records, and Ms. Xia has transferred a total of 28 million cash to Mr. Ruan over the years. "

Xia Xiting and Cheng Taihua said about this matter, and Cheng Taihua was prepared.

Cheng Taihua immediately retorted: "Presiding judge, this is a loan, and the chat record says very clearly, this is a loan." "

Jiang Haochen added: "But it's never been returned, has it?"

Cheng Taihua bit the loan to defend Xia Xiting: "Even if you don't repay it, it's still a loan, and if you have money, you will naturally pay it back." "

Yao Yanxu's lungs were about to explode at this time.

I actually indirectly raised Ruan Qisheng for so many years. (If you read a violent novel, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

28 million, living a chic enough.

"Presiding judge, Mr. Ruan is now opening a restaurant abroad and starting a business, and he has a lot of debts. "

"It's unrealistic for people who can't afford to repay to borrow so much money to go out. "

And Mr. Ruan is also the object of Ms. Xia's extramarital affair, and the party Mr. Yao is completely unaware, this is the transfer of assets. "

Cheng Taihua retorted again: "Didn't Mr. Yao borrow money?

"As far as I know, Mr. Yao has lent at least one million to his friends, Mr. Yao, is that true?"

Jiang Haochen said again: "Presiding judge, the trial, we can look at the chat records again." "

Zhou Ruoyao immediately switched the chat history to where Jiang Haochen needed.

This is the chat transcript from June 2018.

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Xiting, I hope you will get better and better in the future, I hope we will miss it like this again in the future, goodbye. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [What's wrong with you?, why do you suddenly say such things?]

[Ruan Qisheng]: [I opened a fast food restaurant, I can't run it anymore, I owe a lot of money, and my life is over. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [You haven't moved in the past two years, are you running a restaurant?]

Because it can be seen from the chat records above that since Xia Xiting transferred 20,000 yuan to Ruan Qisheng in October 2015, there has not been much chat since then.

In March 2016, Xia Xiting looked for Ruan Qisheng, but never got a reply, which is equivalent to 20,000 yuan directly to Ruan Qisheng.

After more than two years, Ruan Qisheng took the initiative to send a message to Xia Xiting.

At this time, Xia Xiting and Yao Yanxu were already a couple because of no news from Ruan Qisheng in the past two years.

After all, he has been snubbed by the male god for two years, and licking the dog will naturally turn positive.

Not to mention that at that time, Yao Yanxu's career was on the rise. []

[Ruan Qisheng]: [I want to start my own business, I want to be more successful than Yao Yanxu, and snatch you back. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [Don't say that, we've already missed it. 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [Yes, I have missed it forever, I hope you will live happily in the future, and I hope I can stay in your heart forever, farewell. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [Don't think about it, you owe some money, so you won't commit suicide.] 】

[Ruan Qisheng]: [I owe five million, and I can't pay it back. 】

[Xia Xiting]: [With so much money, I can't help it, but I can help you raise 1 million first, you let you pay back part of it first, and then I'll help you find a way.] 】

Because Yao Yanxu and Xia Xiting were not married at that time, Xia Xiting could not get much money.

The latter is to say that Ruan Qisheng thanked Xia Xiting, and Xia Xiting warmly comforted Ruan Qisheng.

After that, Zhou Ruoyao switched the chat history to the relevant records of each time Xia Xiting sent money to Ruan Qisheng.

After showing the chat records, Jiang Haochen said: "Presiding judge, in the trial, every time the other party sells miserably, Ms. Xia took the initiative to say that the money was given to him, and Mr. Ruan finally said that he borrowed it and would pay it back when he had the money." "

"If lending to an extramarital affair partner can be the same as lending it to a friend, then in the future, if you cheat in marriage and transfer assets, you will say that it is good to lend to the cheating partner. "

"So, Lawyer Cheng's point of view, I strongly disagree. "

The presiding judge discussed with the collegial panel and said, "The objection is valid. "

Seeing that the presiding judge agreed with Jiang Haochen's words, Cheng Taihua couldn't help sweating on his forehead.

"Is Lawyer Jiang too sharp?"

"That's too strong, isn't it?"

Chen Muen and Zhao Chuyi were speechless at this time.

The two of them have been lawyers for Cheng Taihua for so long, and they have never seen Cheng Taihua have any lawsuits so passive.

Even if it is to defend the wrong party, Cheng Taihua can say a lot of rebuttals.

But Jiang Haochen's opinions are all ironclad, which makes Cheng Taihua, who has always been able to speak well, dumb and dumb, and he can't say anything about his suffering.

So Jiang Haochen is really a bit strong.

Yao Yanxu was already so angry that he exploded at this time.

If it weren't for seeing the chat records here, Yao Yanxu never dreamed that Xia Xiting would be so humble.

I'm really a clown among clowns.

However, Jiang Haochen's evidence is certainly not as simple as these.

Jiang Haochen continued: "Let me talk about Ms. Xia's other asset transfer behaviors. "

Ms. Xia was in charge of family investment, and in the five and a half years of her marriage to Mr. Yao, she invested in a total of 10 factories, and finally sold them. "

"After some investigation, these factories were eventually bought by several buyers. The company behind these buyers is a company from the island of Mankai abroad. "

"The last actual controllers of these foreign companies in Mankai Island are Ms. Xia's three brothers. "

Ms. Xia achieved the purpose of transferring assets by causing losses on the books of the factory, devaluing the value of the factory, and selling it at a low price. "

"The amount of assets transferred reached 500 million. "

And now after these factories have changed their names, they have continued to cooperate with Mr. Yao's factories in the dark and become suppliers, making at least 300 million profits over the years. "

"If it is not sold, these three hundred million should be the profit attributable to the parent company. "

Hearing this, Yao Yanxu stared at Xia Xiting deadly, he didn't expect that he trusted Xia Xiting so much, Xia Xiting actually used financial means to transfer assets abroad.

"He can find it all?"

Cheng Taihua, Xia Xiting, Chen Muen, and Zhao Chuyi were stunned, and they felt that Jiang Haochen's investigation ability was a little outrageous?

From the time Jiang Haochen began to defend to the present, the initiative was all on Jiang Haochen's side, and it was directly crushed.

Originally, Cheng Taihua also wanted Jiang Haochen to be unable to face him.

But now, Cheng Taihua feels that he is really a little unable to face Jiang Haochen.