If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Chapter 44

I only saw the lawyer at the table.

Ye Qiu smiled slightly and said

"The presiding judge, our client Ruan Feng is a non-professional, and his understanding of vehicle safety obviously comes from the professional information of the other party."

"The other party admitted that the information he conveyed was correct, which means that according to our party's subjective perception, the vehicle only has some conditions, but there are no safety issues."

"This also shows that our client did not subjectively have any foresight of the harm."

Wu De panicked in his heart.

This Ye Qiu's method! He is actually hiding here!

I can't give him a defense of innocence!

Wu De quickly interrupted!

"The other party’s lawyer should not avoid the important and take the easy-！"

"Even if it is not foreseen"

"According to our country's laws, drivers should have the responsibility to check the condition of their vehicles!"

"Ruan Feng realized that there was a problem with the steering wheel, but went on the road without checking the problem. Eventually, the steering wheel failed and caused an accident!"

"He bears the main responsibility!"

In response, Ye Qiu just sneered and said

"Opposing lawyer, don't worry."

"The vehicle owner does have the responsibility to check the condition of the vehicle"

"However, our country’s laws also clearly stipulate"

"Our country's law does stipulate that driving a motor vehicle is a dangerous behavior"

"But this is a dangerous behavior allowed by law and social life"

"As buyers and drivers, citizens do not need to have vehicle-related professional knowledge."

"On the contrary, professional information involving security requires merchants and enterprises to inform them"

"And in this case"

"Our client, Ruan Feng, delivered the vehicle to the insurance company and repair shop for repairs."

"After getting the vehicle, our client conducted a test drive and inspection, and found no other problems except that the steering wheel was not smooth."

"This is obviously because the professional level is not enough to support our client to complete the vehicle safety investigation."

"Therefore, how does our client determine whether the vehicle is safe?"

"That's right, they obtained professional information through defendants Li Zhaohua and Liu Zheng."

"The defendant clearly conveyed the message that the vehicle had no safety issues."

"Therefore, our client does not bear any responsibility for the safety of the vehicle itself"

"Moreover, our client responded promptly when he encountered danger while driving and successfully prevented the first dangerous outcome from occurring."

"That is: avoiding crashing into the rushing tricycle"

"The second dangerous result occurred, namely: hitting a pedestrian and injuring a pedestrian."

"The real key factor is not the failure of the steering wheel, but the sudden failure of the brakes, which prevents the vehicle speed from being reduced."

"And this is an unexpected problem that our party cannot detect and predict. It is obviously a force majeure factor."

"Yes"

"Our client’s traffic accident case was, in fact, a force majeure accident, not an endangerment to public safety as judged and accused by the other party!"

"In addition, we also want to explain something"

"In this accident, Ruan Feng has actively made compensation and obtained a criminal letter of understanding from the victim."

"Therefore, Ruan Feng should not bear any criminal punishment, let alone the unfounded crime of endangering public safety!"

"Because, our client Ruan Feng!"

"He is not guilty!"

Ye Qiu's voice was like thunder on the ground.

It exploded throughout the court hearing.

The whole court was silent!

At this moment, let alone the validity of the factual basis for the first trial!

Even the conclusion of the first trial has been completely overturned!

Ruan Fengcong Ten years in prison turned into a name of innocence!

Everyone!

They were stunned!

The trial was broadcast live.

Netizens felt goosebumps rising!

At this time, they couldn't help shouting excitedly!

"Damn it! pretty! So handsome!"

"Not guilty! Did you hear me! Our client! Not guilty!"

"Mad, my blood boils when I hear it!"

"Is this the charm of pleading! Lawyer Ye is so fierce! What a fraud!"

"Presiding judge, why are you still standing there? You are so quick to sentence me!"

"That’s what lawyer Ye said! Judgment directly!"

At the court hearing.

In the spectator seats!

Ruan's father and Ruan's mother, who had never understood the trial's defense, finally heard two words that shocked their souls.

They couldn't help but stood up excitedly.

"Xiaofeng, are you innocent?"

"Is he not guilty?"

At the plaintiff's table.

Ruan Feng couldn't help but have tears in his eyes!

He looked at his parents

"Yes Yes!"

"Parents, I am not guilty!"

He believes it!

Ye Qiu said he is not guilty!

Then!

He is really innocent!

This scene moved everyone.

Even though their conversation had affected the court.

But the judge did not speak.

Naturally, no one Stop.

At the lawyer's table!

Bai Xiaotu was filled with excitement and excitement! He even couldn't help but want to jump for joy!

Great!

Lawyer Ye!

That's great!

At the prosecutor's table.

Prosecutor Panda's pupils were shaking.

He still felt It's a bit dreamy. Ye Qiu successfully overturned the first-instance verdict just by pleading! This is simply unbelievable! When watching Ruan Feng and his parents celebrating, he suddenly felt that having a lawyer like Ye Qiu here is the best thing. The truth! Fuck it, it’s unbelievable! On the trial bench, the judge Gao Qiang and Li Xiangyang looked at each other. They both felt moved. Ye Qiu’s logic was extremely clear. The logic is interlocking! The legal basis is even more solid! This does not overturn the case. , what else can reverse the verdict?! They even had the urge to applaud! Such a level of plea! It’s really wonderful! And the effect is even more shocking! You really single-handedly saved a family that was on the verge of being broken up! The presiding judge, An Zhengxing, also nodded with undisguised admiration. Ye Qiu had been preparing for one thing from beginning to end, and that was to complete Ruan Feng's innocence defense. This seemed simple, but it was actually very difficult. Because. Even if all four defendants are sent to jail. Ruan Feng, as the perpetrator of the car accident, will still have to bear criminal responsibility. At most, it will be reduced. But now, Ye Qiu miraculously completed Ruan Feng's case through his plea. Innocence defense. This is to truly prevent ordinary people from being wronged. How can a talent with such original intention be really an outlaw? It is really a pity not to enter the public prosecutor's office. Of course. Not all at this time Everyone was happy. In the dock, Wu De looked pale. It's over, it's over! Shen Qiu and others also realized that something was wrong.

"What's going on?!"

"Why was Ruan Feng suddenly innocent?!"

"Wu De, why don’t you ask back quickly?"

Chen Qiu was a little anxious.

Ruan Feng was not guilty.

Isn't that a slap in the face to Ping Sheng?

Being forced by Shen Qiu, Wu De had no choice but to bite the bullet and say

"Opposite lawyer, we do not agree with your conclusion!"

"All your inferences are based on the fact that Ruan Feng failed to detect any hidden dangers in the vehicle!"

"However, according to common sense, Ruan Feng clearly found a problem with the steering wheel during the test drive, so he could also find a problem with the brakes."

"Therefore, ask the other party’s lawyer to show......."

Wu De didn't finish his words.

Ye Qiu interrupted in a calm tone.

"Our country’s legal provisions"

"Who claims and who gives evidence"

"Ask the other party's defender to present strong evidence that our client clearly discovered the brake problem himself."

"In other words, the defendant actually knew that there was a problem with the brakes and had informed our client, but this was evidence that our client ignored!"

As soon as he said this,

Shen Qiu frowned and looked ugly.

Li Zhaohua and Liu Zheng said repeatedly

"We had no idea there was a problem with the brakes!"

"This is none of our business!"

And Wu De is under great pressure.

His mind is running crazy.

Now is the last time! (To read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!) You must find an opportunity before the presiding judge makes a decision! Suddenly Wu De had a flash of inspiration. He said loudly

"Opposite lawyer!"[]

"The brakes in your statement failed!"

"In fact, it has been expressing that there is a problem with the vehicle itself!"

"However, there is also a possibility that the brake failure was caused by Ruan Feng's behavior!"

As soon as he said this, the Internet exploded!

"O Minos! Maybe it’s all members!"

"Cao! Litigation stick! How shameless! No shame!"

"What's the difference between this and Zhao Lidong! Drag it out quickly!"

"Where's the bailiff! The bailiff comes and drags me away!"

And the court hearing scene was also completely stunned.

Are you so shameless?

Of course Wu De is shameless.

But compared to losing the case, what is face?

At this time, Wu De stabilized his mentality and said quickly

"Presiding Judge, our appeal is not unfounded!"

"In fact, quite a few car owners will make corresponding modifications to their vehicles"

"These modifications are carried out privately, so these modifications are not within the scope of maintenance of the repair shop, and they are not without the possibility of affecting the braking effect!"

"Therefore, we apply to determine the brake failure caused by Ruan Feng’s personal behavior!"

Hearing Wu De's words, the presiding judge An Zhengxing frowned.

From a personal standpoint, he was very reluctant to talk to Wu De.

But from a legal standpoint, what Wu De said was actually not unreasonable.

Many times , it is true that private car owners will modify their vehicles, causing various failures, but generally the problems are not serious.

This Wu De, obviously deliberately delays the time.

However,

An Zhengxing can't help it.

Sometimes judges who stick to the bottom line are like this This kind of helplessness.

You know that the other party is causing trouble, but you have to give the other party a chance.

However,

An Zhengxing does not intend to solve this matter by himself.

Isn’t there a lawless maniac in this situation?

It depends on whether he can give Surprised myself!

"Litigation lawyer, do you have anything to say? Ye

Qiu said with a smile.

"Some presiding judges."

An Zhengxing nodded happily.

"Okay, start your statement."

At this time,

Wu De stared at Ye Qiu closely.

In fact, his psychological pressure was not great anymore.

Because he deliberately raised this possibility, it was not to win at all, let alone to make a comeback.

His purpose was very Simple!

Just delay!

Even if Ye Qiu says who advocates and who provides evidence!

He will follow without hesitation!

It means that we will collect evidence!

Then we can delay the pace naturally!

The best result is to let the presiding judge A verdict cannot be made this time! This way they can win the chance of the next trial!

In the meantime, they can find more escape routes! Wu De had to admit one thing. Even now, Ye Qiu has not produced a single piece of evidence.. But it can be said that it has killed the court trial. Their victory has no possibility of winning! Therefore, protecting one's own retreat is the most helpless but also the last choice!

"Wait, does he really have no evidence?"

Suddenly Wu De saw Ye Qiu's half-smiling expression.

He felt a little dizzy.

It's impossible!

He has evidence!

Why didn't he bring it out earlier?!

Why didn't Ye Qiu bring out the evidence earlier?

Because it was brought out earlier! If so, the benefits will not be maximized.

There will not even be the unexpected gain of Zhao Lidong.

At this time, it is the time to present the evidence.

Ye Qiu calmly took out a piece of material, looked at Wu De with a smile and said

"We present evidence"

"This is the consumption record related to the vehicles owned by our client."

"This does not include any private installation costs"

"At the same time, this is the vehicle inspection report before it was sent to Pingsheng for inspection. The configuration of the vehicle is exactly the same as when it left the factory."

"In addition, I would like to ask the prosecutor, did the law enforcement agency conduct an inspection on our client’s vehicle after the accident?"

Panda, the prosecutor of the prosecution, looked through the materials and said

"There is a certain level of inspection"

"No traces of modifications related to the braking function were found."

Ye Qiu said with a smile.

"Thank you prosecutor for your answer."

The prosecution is really cooperative. It's a direct united front.

Then Wu De's face became increasingly pale.

Ye Qiu did not stop.

Instead, he asked Ruan Fengdao

"Mr. Ruan, why didn’t you modify the vehicle? Ruan

Feng replied at this time

"Because this car is a two million luxury car, and my main role is to pick up friends and participate in competitions with myself"

"So although I like driving very much, I don’t dare to modify it easily because I am afraid of causing safety risks."

"I guarantee that what I say is true and bear all legal responsibilities"

"OK, thanks for the answer."

At this moment.

Wu Deren is completely stupid!

Why the hell do you have any evidence?

How come you are ready for everything!

Could it be that the current scene has been within your expectations!?

Damn it!

How can you still play with it? Ah!

Wu De felt unprecedented pressure and almost fell into depression.

What the hell, he even slapped him!

Ye Qiu smiled and said to An Zhengxing

"presiding judge"

"End of our statement"

"Application for determination of facts."

Presiding judge An Zhengxing nodded with a smile, then struck the gavel and said

"Now we will judge the fact that Ruan Feng deliberately endangered public safety in a dangerous way!"

"The factual basis of the first instance was insufficient and the evidence was judged to be invalid. The judgment of the first instance was revoked!"

"Ruan Feng had no subjective intention or negligence, and his traffic accident was a force majeure accident!"

"In addition, because Ruan Feng has completed the reconciliation with the victim, he does not bear any charges!"

"Therefore, this court’s verdict! Ruan Feng is not guilty!"

"Moreover, due to the prosecutor's mistakes, Ruan Feng suffered unnecessary losses!"

"In accordance with the National Compensation Law, the prosecution and law enforcement agencies are ordered to compensate Ruan Feng 27,664 yuan and 75 cents!"

"Are the parties wrong to object?"

Plaintiff Ye Qiu:"We have no objection."

Prosecutor Panda:" We have no objection."

Defendant Wu De:"......We have no objection."

Boom!"

A huge gavel sounded!

The presiding judge An Zhengxing said solemnly

"The judgment takes effect!"

"Ruan Feng was acquitted in court!"

Hearing this,

Ruan Feng and his parents were completely excited.

"Thank you, Judge!"