If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Chapter 67

PS: There are some logic errors in the first two chapters, and they have been revised to a certain extent. In order to ensure the reading experience, you can re-read the previous chapters when you catch up on this chapter. There will be no repeated deductions, and the number of words will only be more, not less..

When Ye Qiu read Xu Ming's information.

In fact, the system's database has been opened.

View all information without missing a beat.

The story of this case is very simple.

In June this year, I was at Tang Duyi Barbecue Shop.

Nine social men, headed by Gan Wuxin, caused a conflict after they failed to strike up a conversation with two women sitting next to them after drinking.

Then the extremely arrogant Gan Wuxin and others violently dragged the two women out of the store and carried out extremely brutal beatings on the spot. Multiple people took turns beating them.

The entire assault lasted for five minutes, and the methods were extremely cruel, including but not limited to dragging him by his hair, kicking his head, hitting him with a stool, and hitting him with a bottle... The surveillance video of the barbecue restaurant clearly recorded this scene.

The woman who was mainly beaten was named Jiang Ge. She was knocked to the ground all the time. The blood stains on her body were clearly visible. She was almost semi-conscious and in a very miserable state.

Moreover, Gan Wuxin, one of the main perpetrators, was committing violent acts while arrogantly shouting,"I'll beat you to death." He didn't stop even if Jiang Ge stopped resisting.

The arrogant attitude and cruel behavior can be said to make everyone and God angry.

Things have come to this.

In fact, it was enough to arouse the most enthusiastic public opinion and ignite verbal and written criticism across the Internet.

The subsequent development usually involves the exposure of the video, and then the judicial department intervenes and law enforcement agencies strike hard.

Arrest and bring the perpetrators to justice, investigate their criminal background, and carry out relevant rectification.

But what happened next.

The whole case took a turn and became more complicated.

First, when the beating started, bystanders called the police, but law enforcement officers did not arrive at the scene.

Then Chen Yue, a woman who was lightly beaten, saw her friend Jiang Ge being beaten until she became unresponsive. As time went by, Gan Wuxin's violent behavior not only did not stop, but became more violent.

So Chen Yue, who was nervous, called the police and shouted that the police were coming soon.

This aroused even greater anger from Gan Wuxin and others, and they turned to focus on Chen Yue.

After a violent beating, Gan Wuxin dragged Chen Yue directly into the alley next to him and continued the violence. During this period, Chen Yue kept crying for help and screaming.

Jiang Ge, who woke up later, saw this scene and rushed into the alley. Afterwards, a burst of chaos broke out. Jiang Ge used a bottle full of wine to hit Gan Wuxin crazily and beat him to death.

This scene caused shock and panic among the other eight perpetrators, and the original violence stopped completely.

Soon after, law enforcement officers arrived and arrested Jiang Ge and Chen Yue. As for the eight violent men, they left the scene early.

Of course.

This is all the truth that Ye Qiu saw.

This is not the information provided by Xu Ming.

To be precise.

The information provided by Xu Ming is not comprehensive.

For example, there was no situation after Chen Yue was dragged into the alley.

At the same time, there is no information about what happened after law enforcement officers arrived at the scene.

Just a simple summary.

In the midst of a conflict in an alley.

Jiang Ge deliberately killed Gan Wuxin.

He was eventually caught on the spot by law enforcement officers.

The prosecutor subsequently filed an indictment for intentional homicide.

"......"

Ye Qiu narrowed his eyes slightly.

While tapping the table with his long fingers.

While thinking about it. in this case.

What Ye Qiu wants to do.

It is to defend the murderer Jiang Ge to reduce his sentence.

As for the ultimate goal of defense.

Xu Ming didn't say anything. but.

Ye Qiu already had an idea. at this time.

Xu Ming on the side did not speak.

Instead, he observed Ye Qiu with great interest.

He wanted to know how Ye Qiu would ask questions and how to start. this case.

It's easy to say simple.

It's complicated to say the least.

The simplicity lies in the fact that things are clear, the evidence is conclusive, and there are no surprises.

The complexity is that public opinion has already fermented, and everyone is generally very sympathetic to the defendant Jiang Ge.

The most important thing is that they are very disgusted with the perpetrators of the accusation. Countless people even demanded that the perpetrators be investigated and Jiang Ge acquitted.

However, the biggest key to this case is this.

The fact that Jiang Ge committed murder intentionally is very clear, and the prosecution's evidence chain is very complete.

At the same time, Jiang Ge has pleaded guilty, that is, he admitted that he committed murder intentionally.

As for the crime of intentional homicide, it is extremely difficult to reduce the sentence if the perpetrator pleads guilty.

Due to legal provisions, Jiang Ge must bear responsibility.

However, due to public opinion, they had to seek a commutation of Jiang Ge's sentence.

And the more you lose, the better.

This is the biggest contradiction and difficulty.

The final settlement of such cases.

There is only a trial plea.

Therefore, it relies heavily on the strength of the defense lawyer.

Which aspect of the law Ye Qiu plans to start with and how to prepare for the prosecution's defense are very important, but at the same time, the room for development is very limited.

The prosecutor has irrefutable evidence, so it is impossible to start with factual identification, and there is very little room to start with legal identification.

After all, there is a lot of subjectivity in legal interpretation, and not everyone will agree with your legal interpretation.

Therefore, this type of case is a great test of personal ability.

Although the Supreme Court no longer assesses Ye Qiu.

But this Tangdu murder case is still an experiment.

After all, there is a certain similarity with the special Supreme Court case that is about to be heard.

Of course.

Compared to special cases.

Tangdu Murder Case is relatively simple in all aspects.

Xu Ming could easily find several points to defend the defendant's sentence reduction.

For example.

There were corresponding taint on the part of the plaintiff, which was a strong argument for a reduced sentence.

In addition, the Tangdu murder case mainly dealt with the pressure of public opinion, and it was not too high.

Therefore, as long as the case is given a certain degree of lightness and dealt with accordingly.

I'm not saying it's a perfect solution, but at least there won't be any problems.

However, a special case of the Supreme Court.

The people and situations involved are more complex, the troubles to be dealt with are greater, there are more things to balance, and the requirements for defense are higher.

To put it simply, when the law is followed, neither party can be tainted and both must be innocent. However, intentional homicide is a fact, and the person killed is not simple.

Therefore, the whole case is very embarrassing for people and the current law.

Even if Xu Ming thinks about it for a moment, he feels like his head is going to explode.

In his view, it would be almost impossible to deal with that particular case perfectly unless the law was specifically amended. but.

Xu Ming doesn't want to think too much now.

Anyway, this trouble will be Ye Qiu's in the future.

Xu Ming is more interested now.

What did Ye Qiu think about the Tangdu murder case?

Will he bring some surprises to the top department?

If Ye Qiu really has a perfect idea.

Perhaps that particular case faced by the Supreme Court.

It really can be solved easily. at this time.

When Ye Qiu reviewed the truth of the case.

Bai Xiaotu was also looking at the information and browsing relevant information online.

Public opinion on this case is very high online.

Even higher than scholarship cases.

Because of this case.

For members of the entire society, there is a strong sense of substitution, even a sense of fear.

The prelude to the Tangdu murder case was the Tangdu beating case. Gan Wuxin and others blatantly ignored the law and morality, used rampant violence, and committed serious violent violations against Jiang Ge and Chen Yue, who were strangers to them.

Its bad nature, in the eyes of netizens, even goes far beyond the murder itself.

Therefore, even if it happened a few months ago, the total number of views of various related videos on all platforms exceeded one billion.

And as the trial is about to begin, the popularity continues to rise, and there are even a lot of news specifically to stir up controversy.

【In the face of violence, how can we protect ourselves and fight back against others?】

【If you are violently injured and kill someone, should you bear legal responsibility?】

【Intentional murder, if the person killed is a bad person, is it not guilty? Or indefinitely? Or the death penalty?】

【The Tangdu murder case is about to begin, what will be the fate of Jiang Ge? How will the judge judge? 】

And the comments below.

It's almost always one-sided. (To read exciting novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

"This media is a hammer, why should I ask? It must be innocent!"

"yes! You didn't look at the surveillance. They were beaten so badly, it was so inhumane! Although I didn't see the video in the alley, Chen Yue's scream was extremely miserable. If he didn't kill Gan Wuxin at this time, would he have to wait until he was killed by a strong alkali before killing him?"

"Yes, I said Jiang Ge killed well! What responsibility do you have? To me, it's directly defined as fighting!"

"Mad, a bunch of people almost killed me, so why can’t I kill him?"

"well said! Gan Wuxin and the others are just a bunch of black men! Jiang Ge killed people from the Heise Society to eliminate harm for the people! Clean up the environment for the country! It deserves a big reward!"

"By the way, have you noticed why the law enforcement officers arrived last? Didn't anyone call the police in the first place?"

"Let me tell you, it’s not just law enforcement officers who have problems! The men who were watching were also accomplices! As a man, he didn’t take the initiative to protect the girl! What a birth!"

"The boxers upstairs, get out of here! If he can't speak, just shut up. You can't see those nine men. Who dares to go up and save people? Moreover, someone in the video tried to stop him and was beaten up!"

"Yes, if he provokes a confrontation, labor and management will come to you offline! Now the dark forces are harming ordinary people, and ordinary people are resisting! It has nothing to do with gender!"

"Ignore the opposing 500,000 yuan, let's get down to business. I really doubt the law enforcement agencies now, because as far as I know, someone called the police as soon as possible, but the result never came. It was only after Jiang Ge killed Gan Wuxin that Arrived instantly"

"Mad, there is definitely an inside story to this! Those men are so arrogant, there really is someone behind them!"

"Damn it, a bunch of gangsters dare to sue anyone? Why didn't the judge send them in first?!"

"......"

All comments.

Almost all of them called for Jiang Ge to be acquitted.

Then severely deal with Gan Wuxin and others.

Bai Xiaotu agrees very much with this.

And after understanding the matter.

I felt even more indignant.

She turned the computer screen to Ye Qiu and couldn't help but ask[]

"｀Lawyer Ye"

"Can you help Jiang Ge defend his innocence?"

"Although Gan Wuxin died, their violence was the cause of everything."

"This should be excusable! Even if the law cannot ignore reason! Jiang Ge killed people to protect himself! Is it self-defense?!"

Xu Ming shook his head slightly when he heard the words.

Of course he understood Bai Xiaotu's thoughts.

At the same time, he also felt the same way about the comments on the Internet.

But the law is the law.

In addition to protecting the rights of the victim, the law also protects the rights of the perpetrator.

And protect the perpetrator. Rights and interests are essentially intended to limit the power of judicial organs and prevent unlimited power from harming ordinary people.

Therefore, the theory that netizens say that if you kill well, you will not be responsible, it is just out of simple moral values, and it is fundamental in law It won't work.

Otherwise one day the judiciary will eventually prevail over everyone. Anyone who makes a small mistake may suffer the most severe judicial blow. That is terrible. This is the case in the Tangshan murder case.

Even if Gan Wuxin and the others are black Yes, but it is a fact that Jiang Ge committed murder intentionally.

These two things cannot be confused. Even if Gan Wuxin is punished, Jiang Ge cannot be exempted from the crime of murder. It is already very good to be able to reduce it to a certain extent.

As for being justified. Defense? This is impossible.

Intentional killing cannot be considered as legitimate defense.

At this time,

Ye Qiu has already thought about it.

He looked at the news comments that Bai Xiaotu forwarded.

Regarding the netizens shouting"Good kill" , to eliminate harm for the people, Ye Qiu expressed his understanding and agreement.

Ye Qiu saw it clearly.

Although the beating case in Tangdu only harmed women's rights, in essence, it destroyed the safety of the entire society, which made The general people's sense of security has been shattered.

After all, who wants to worry about being beaten or even beaten randomly by others while"eating hot pot and singing" in a public environment with bright lights and people coming and going? What about more serious violations?

Besides, even if it comes to men and women themselves, who of us has a wife, children, and who doesn’t worry about his family being harmed outside?

When the Tangdu murder case came out, it was everywhere on the Internet (Nonuo Zhao) Screenshots of various messages from parents, asking their children to go home early, not to go out for activities, and not to provoke others.

Even if you are really unfortunate enough to offend someone, you must give in in time and never cause consequences such as killing someone..

This situation naturally made netizens feel widespread anger.

Therefore,

Ye Qiu's goal is very clear.

His defense requirements are very simple, that is, not guilty.

Not only innocent, but also counter-indicted for all The perpetrator, and even the law enforcement agency.

At this time,

Xu Ming also looked at Ye Qiu

"What does Lawyer Ye specifically think about Jiang Ge’s defense goal of commuting his sentence?"

In Xu Ming's view,

Bai Xiaotu is still a college student after all.

He is full of passion and values justice more than the law.

But Ye Qiu is different.

Although Ye Qiu also values fairness and justice, his methods are very sophisticated and his mentality is very stable..

In intentional homicide cases, it is destined to be impossible to be innocent, but if the sentence can be reduced, we still hope to reduce the sentence as much as possible. Try to achieve a balance between emotion and law, which is also Xu Ming's hope. When Xu Ming spoke, so did Bai Xiaotu He looked at Ye Qiu expectantly.

He only saw Ye Qiu laughing softly, and then said

"The goal, of course, is to be innocent."

Bai Xiaotu was delighted when he heard this!

"Great!"

I jumped for joy.

It seemed that I had won the case.

Xu Ming was not particularly surprised when he heard this. The goal is just a goal, and it is not that simple to achieve the actual demands.

Therefore, Xu Ming just said rationally

"It is impossible to be innocent of intentional homicide."

"Of course, it is still possible to achieve the maximum reduction of sentence with this goal. Ye

Qiu said with a smile.

"Who says intentional homicide cannot be innocent?"