If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Court trial live broadcast room.

Netizens are all excited

"Damn it, the presiding judge just rebelled!"

"Turn the gun and attack the emperor! Ha ha ha ha! Look at the expressions on the faces of the legal affairs officers of the Imperial Enterprises, they are almost turning into pig livers!

"Haha, cool! It has to be Lawyer Ye!"

"Not only did he dare to reject the judgment of the presiding judge, but he also forced the presiding judge to surrender! Flowing Beer Plus!"

"It is true that Lawyer Ye’s legal explanation is too strong!"

"Unless the presiding judge dares to challenge the law, he will definitely listen to Lawyer Ye!"

"Unexpectedly, Lawyer Ye’s court hearings in civil cases were also dimensionality reduction attacks! fierce!"

"I am now more and more curious about what evidence Ye Lu prepared!"

"I'm also curious. It would be best if this evidence could be sent to Emperor Qi!"

"Just out of curiosity, speaking of Teacher Zhang San, can Lawyer Ye really have evidence to send to Emperor Qi?"

Zhang San couldn't laugh or cry when he heard this.

"You just want to give it away, right? It’s obvious that you are a big fan of Lawyer Ye!

Netizen:"Hey, a ten-year-old fan, here uninvited!""

"Haha, does Professor Zhang San only know now?"

Zhang San shook his head helplessly and began to explain.

"This link is the link to determine plagiarism."

"The evidence presented by Lawyer Ye must be related to the fact-finding of plagiarism."

"Obviously this cannot be given away."

"If you really want to give it away, it will be the next step in determining unfair competition."

"Because unfair competition includes the commercial bribery mentioned by Lawyer Ye, which is serious and can indeed be punished.

Netizen:"Then ask the amazing teacher Zhang San, does Lawyer Ye have evidence of this commercial bribery?""

Zhang San:"......"

How the hell do I know!

If only I knew!

Then am I not on the same level as Ye Qiu?!

Then why don’t I go and make a name for myself and reach the highest level, instead of just showing it live here for you?

Zhang San couldn't help but complain in his heart.

However, he still explained with the mentality of being a teacher.

"I don't know this either"

"I can only say that it is very possible."

"After all, Attorney Ye’s court trial style is famous for being comprehensive."

"As you just heard, Lawyer Ye submitted all the information about the chess and card games even before the trial."

"Not to mention how troublesome the preparation for this is."

"Only Lawyer Ye can prepare this thing"

"This means that Lawyer Ye has already predicted the operation of Diwang Enterprise Legal Affairs"

"Therefore, with Attorney Ye’s almost omniscient court hearing style, since he has made a request, he must be prepared."

Hearing what Zhang San said, netizens instantly started to look forward to it.

The infringement case was given away!

The gift was from Imperial Enterprise!

This is so worth looking forward to!

Shendu.

Imperial Enterprise headquarters.

Seeing Zhang San's answer,

Ma Huaxun frowned. He frowned and said in a deep voice.

"Zhang Haocun, during your conversations with major platforms, did you encounter any problems?"

As a top capitalist, Ma Huaxun saw that the imperial company was at a disadvantage in the court trial. For a moment, he smelled something bad.

Therefore, Ma Huaxun was very dissatisfied.

Facing the pressure from Ma Huaxun, Zhang Haocun, the director of operations, felt a little bit in his heart Flustered, but still answered quickly

"Chairman, this three is just nonsense from Ye Qiu's point of view."

"The removal of Qingshu Studio games was decided by major platforms after seeing the strength of our Imperial Enterprise and hoping to retain their cooperation with us."

"This is not unfair competition, let alone commercial bribery."

"Don't worry, Chairman, we will definitely win this lawsuit!"

Ma Huaxun was noncommittal when he heard the words. He just glanced at Zhang Haocun.

Then he looked at the court hearing screen coldly.

"You'd better not have any dirty hands or feet."

He doesn't care if his subordinates break the law, but if it is exposed, don't blame him. At this moment,

Zhang Haocun was extremely nervous.

At the same time, he couldn't understand it at all.

How did Ye Qiu know about his bribery? Even the emperor No one at the top of the company knew about it!

When Emperor Enterprise had just developed a game that copied Qingshu Studio, Zhang Haocun was just a supervisor in the operations department, but he keenly discovered the profit potential of this game.

Therefore, he directly reported to Ma Huaxun He issued a military order and took over the task of promoting [Alliance Clash].

As a small supervisor, he did not have much capital to represent the Imperial Enterprise and make all mobile game platforms bow their heads.

However, Zhang Haocun understood the truth of being reluctant to let go of your children and not being able to ensnare the wolf. So I directly spent money to bribe the senior management of a major mobile game platform, so that the other party would be the first to remove Qingshu Studio’s original game [Tribal War].

This operation was risky, but the rewards were extremely generous.

With the entire network The platform removed Green Tree Studio's games, and Imperial Enterprise's [Alliance Clash] came out on top, bringing huge revenue.

As a result, Zhang Haocun was promoted to the director of the operations department and received a lot of benefits.

However, he did not expect that he would not be happy for long.

Qingshu Studio actually found Ye Qiu and filed a second trial!

What's even more outrageous is that Ye Qiu actually knew about his commercial bribery!

How is this possible?!

"This must be a charge Ye Qiu made casually in order to win the lawsuit. He couldn't have any evidence!"

Zhang Haocun was constantly analyzing in his mind. He calmed down for the time being.

However, he was also paying close attention to the court hearing.

At this moment, he had never hoped that Emperor Legal Affairs would win. At the court hearing, under the gaze of everyone,

Ye Qiu Buxu took out a piece of material and spoke calmly.

"This is the evaluation of the two games conducted by our survey of one hundred professional practitioners in the game field."

"And we surveyed one hundred ordinary people who have never been exposed to mobile games to evaluate the two games."

"Both serve as control groups"

"The analysis results of professional practitioners are: the core gameplay of the two games is completely the same"

"The evaluation results of ordinary people are very interesting."

"I played Clash of Alliances first and think Clash of Clans is plagiarism."

"I played Clash of Clans first and think Clash of Alliances is plagiarism."

"Whether in the eyes of professionals or in the perception of the general public,"

"The two games are highly similar and have the same core gameplay."

When Ye Qiu said this, he glanced at the dock lightly, and finally smiled calmly.

"Now let me answer the question that I just asked the other party’s lawyer and couldn’t answer."

"The original core gameplay and krypton gold structure of our game have passed the verification of the market and been recognized by consumers, showing great profitability."

"Emperor Enterprise knows that if it changes the core elements, it will be impossible to obtain the game profitability of our game."

"Therefore, they chose to completely copy our game"

"Therefore, combined with other materials we have provided"

"The fact that the other party plagiarized has been determined"

"Ask the presiding judge to determine that the other party has plagiarized."

Ye Qiu finished speaking.

On the dock,

Zhou Kai and Liu Xuan's faces were ashen.

This Ye Qiu!

Why is he prepared for everything!

Is he the only one that's outrageous!

And on the trial bench,

Sun Zhiming and Wang Haiyue listened to Ye Qiu's words..

Continuously flipping through relevant materials for verification.

Finally, he raised his head and couldn't help but glance at Ye Qiu, his heart was shocked.

"Does Ye Qiu have a God's perspective?!"

"How come he has everything ready?"

They couldn't help but be shocked.

Because Ye Qiu'sThe review ability is simply frighteningly comprehensive.

If Song Huihuang just judged Emperor Qi as plagiarizing.

There is no problem in the application of the law because it is ignored in favor of the imperial enterprise.

But in terms of fact-finding, I really don’t blame the presiding judge, because who knew that the materials provided by Ye Qiu were so comprehensive and effective?

The collegial panel just briefly reviewed the plaintiff's materials before making its decision. This does not mean that they are irresponsible.

But because of plagiarism cases, many appellants will provide a large amount of various materials with the intention of proving the fact that the defendant has plagiarized.

But in fact, 80% of the materials here are useless.

But Ye Qiu is different.

His material is not only comprehensive.

And they all work!

Including that lengthy, information on all board games!

And now the supplementary materials provided by Ye Qiu are even more amazing!

Although it is not evidence, it can also be used as auxiliary proof.

Combined with Ye Qiu's comprehensive and fierce defense, as long as Emperor Qi cannot provide valid evidence to refute.

Then, they're done.

In the seat of the presiding judge.

At this time, Song Huihuang directly sounded the gavel.

"Defendant, do you have any objections?"

"Do you state the legal basis or present factual evidence?"

Zhou Kai, Liu Xuan:"......"

They can come up with some damn evidence! but.

Again. (To read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

Emperor Qi cannot lose the plagiarism lawsuit.

Because Zhou Kai had to rack his brains to think about the reasons.

Then, he grasped a very reluctant point and said

"Chief judge, we believe that the research results presented by the other party cannot be used as evidence, so we apply to reject the other party's statement!"

The three judges almost couldn't help rolling their eyes when they heard this.

Of course I know that it can't be used as evidence!

But does this affect the effectiveness of Ye Qiu's statement?

Not only does it not affect it, but Zhou Kai's quibbling behavior strengthens it even more. The effect of Ye Qiu's statement.

Then,

Song Huanghuang banged the gavel and said directly

"Agree with the defendant’s application grounds"

"Basis for consent: The plaintiff’s investigation results cannot be used as evidence"

"Deny the defendant's application"

"Basis for rejection: The plaintiff’s statement complies with applicable law and factual findings, and is sufficiently effective."

Zhou Kai, Liu Xuan:"......"

Song Huihuang's reasons are clear and clear.

There is no room for rebuttal.

Suddenly, a sense of powerlessness and panic filled both of their bodies.[]

Is Imperial Enterprise really going to lose this lawsuit?

How will they get back to the legal department then? at this time.

Court trial live broadcast room.

Netizens laughed

"Agree with your reasons and reject your request! Hahaha! The presiding judge knows how to play!"

"This imperial company's legal affairs has directly broken through the defense! Ha ha!"

"Wait, why don’t I understand? If you agree to the reasons, shouldn’t you agree to the application? How can it still be done like this?"

"Teacher Zhang San, please teach me!"

Zhang San smiled and explained when he saw this.

"In fact, the presiding judge made it very clear"

"Lawyer Ye's research results, if strictly investigated, do not have corresponding legal benefits and therefore cannot be used as evidence."

"This is actually the reason why Lawyer Ye submitted it as supplementary material in court instead of submitting it directly as evidence."

"The presiding judge clearly understood and therefore agreed with the defendant’s reasoning"

"But"

"Imperial Enterprise’s legal affairs team wanted to use this point to reject all of Lawyer Ye’s statements."

"This is not possible because Lawyer Ye’s statement itself is valid. This material serves more of an auxiliary explanation and strengthens the presiding judge’s tendency."

"If you want to reject Lawyer Ye's statement, you need to present valid evidence to prove that Lawyer Ye's factual determination is wrong."

"But obviously, Imperial Corporate Legal Affairs can’t come up with it at all."

"Therefore, the presiding judge rejected their application"

"This operation is actually very smart"

"On the one hand, it maintains the majesty of the law"

"On the one hand, it actually hit the legal affairs of Imperial Enterprises."

"Let them know one thing clearly. Without evidence, don’t think about confusing right and wrong."

"In fact, this also proves one thing"

"The presiding judge has fully sided with Lawyer Ye."

"In other words, we are on the side of the truth."

"Lawyer Ye forcefully turned the Blue Mountain home court of Imperial Enterprises into his own home court."

"If the emperor tries, he will lose."

After hearing Zhang San's words, netizens became even more excited.

"Lawyer Ye is dripping with beer!Then overturned the home court of the Imperial Enterprise!"

"Lawyer Ye: From now on, I have the final say in the Blue Mountain Court!"

"Hahaha! Call here! Ye Shen Court!!!"

The scene of the trial.

The presiding judge Song Huanghuang took a look at the materials, struck the gavel and said

"The core gameplay and monetization structure of [Alliance Clash] are original creations of Green Tree Studio. Does the defendant have any objections?"

"If you have any objections, please submit relevant evidence."

Zhou Kai:"....Presiding Judge, we maintain our original view."

Song Huanghuang:?

That means there is no evidence?

You said to keep the hammer without evidence!

Don't say that I didn't remind the emperor Qiha!

Dong-dong!

Song Huanghuang struck the gavel seriously and said

"Summary of the current stage"

"Concerning the controversy over the fact that Imperial Enterprise’s [Alliance Clash] plagiarized Green Tree Studio’s [Tribal War]"

"The plaintiff stated and presented effective legal basis and factual basis"

"The defendant did not present relevant evidence and proof of non-plagiarism, and had no legal basis to support it."

The previous judgment was contradicted by Ye Qiu.

Song Huanghuang not only changed his position, but also directly improved his memory.

This time, he arranged the legal process clearly and did not give the Imperial Enterprise any chance to cause trouble.

After all, if the Imperial Enterprise does not want In terms of face, not to mention rejecting it like Ye Qiu, but you can still apply for other delays.

And now, this is a live broadcast trial. An accident is already very serious. If you add something else, then this trial can be said to be terrible. , the chief judge must bear the responsibility

"Do both parties have anything to add to the current plagiarism dispute?"

Plaintiff Ye Qiu:"We have nothing to add."

Defendant Zhou Kai:"......We have nothing to add."

Dong dong!

Song Huanghuang knocked the gavel decisively and said

"Both parties have no additions or objections!"

"This court is currently making a decision!"

"The Alliance Clash game produced by Imperial Enterprises is suspected of plagiarizing the Tribal War game produced by Green Tree Studio"

"Reason for judgment: Green Tree Studio’s game [Clash of Clans] has unique core gameplay and monetization structure."

"In these two points, the game of Emperor Qi is essentially similar to the game of Qingshu Studio, and they are highly similar."！

"Therefore, it constitutes plagiarism under the Copyright Law!"

"Do both parties have any objections?"

Ye Qiu smiled slightly.

"We have no objection."

Cold sweat broke out on Zhou Kai's forehead.

We can't let this judgment be finalized!

The emperor cannot lose the plagiarism lawsuit!

Zhou Kai took a deep breath and said

"Chief Judge, our application for this judgment is invalid, and we would like to provide additional explanations!"

Song Huanghuang said expressionlessly.

"The application is invalid!"

"Both parties had been asked whether they would make supplements, and the defendant clearly chose to give up."

"The judgment result is now determined"

"If the defendant insists on its application"

"Administrative reconsideration can be filed after the court is closed."

"The current judicial process continues. If the defendant disrupts the court for this reason again, he will be expelled from the court on the grounds of obstruction of justice."

Zhou Kai, Liu Xuan:"......"

Boom!

Song Huihuang completely ignored the defendant!

Ringing the gavel solemnly

"Now!"

"Let’s proceed to the next stage of defending the disputed points!"

"That is: Is the behavior of Imperial Enterprise suspected of unfair competition?".