Lawyer's character

Fang Yi thinks what Deng Junshan said is logical. Whoever broadcasts with a loudspeaker while sleeping is not likely to show it to others, so it is difficult to find witnesses.

"How do you explain the half-length wooden sticks and string gloves in your pigsty?" the female prosecutor asked.

"I really don't know when the things you mentioned arrived in my pigsty. I go out to work every day, and my wife has to take care of the crops in the fields. There is often no one at home. Someone must have framed me. , I threw it on purpose." Deng Junshan replied innocently.

…

"The following is the presentation and cross-examination of evidence. Do the prosecutors, defenders, and defendants have any new evidence that needs to be submitted?" the presiding judge asked.

"There is no new evidence." The three parties replied.

"It's up to the prosecutor to present evidence," the presiding judge said.

“The first piece of evidence is the on-site inspection, inspection records and photos.

According to the on-site inspection, inspection records and photos provided by the public security organs, the scene was located at Deng Lu's house in Dengjia Village; the door of the master bedroom where Deng Lu and his wife lived was closed, and there was a 40 cm long and 2.5 cm in diameter on the ground in front of the door, shaped like A wooden stick on the handle of a hoe; there was obviously violent turmoil in the master bedroom, and items were piled all over the floor; the injured Jiao Shangying was lying among the debris on the ground, with his feet and hands tied with a hemp rope; there was a wooden box on the earthen bed, and inside the box Valuable items had been looted; Deng Lu was killed on the kang, his face covered in blood, and his arms had obvious multiple resistance wounds; there was a lot of blood on the bedding on the kang.

On the afternoon after the incident, a pair of thread gloves and a wooden stick were found in the pig pen in Deng Junshan's yard. The wooden stick was the same thickness as the wooden stick left on the ground outside the crime scene. Both wooden sticks were the same size. There are marks on one end that have just been sawed, and the cross-section marks are basically consistent, indicating that the same wooden stick has been separated into two pieces. "

"What objection does the defendant Deng Junshan have to the evidence?" the presiding judge asked.

"I have objections. I don't know where the half stick came from. I don't have such a thing at home." Deng Junshan looked a little anxious.

"What does the defendant's defender have to say about the evidence?" The presiding judge looked at the defense table.

"The defender has no objection to the authenticity of the first piece of evidence, but this evidence cannot prove that the defendant is the murderer, let alone that the defendant committed a home invasion and robbery." Fang Yi said.

"The prosecutor continues to present evidence," the presiding judge said.

Next, the prosecutor presented the second piece of evidence, and the DNA identification conclusion confirmed that the "blood on the wooden stick on the ground in front of the crime scene" submitted for inspection was the mixed blood of Deng Lu and his wife. The third piece of evidence, the autopsy conclusion confirmed that the victim Deng Lu was hit on the head with a blunt instrument and died of severe craniocerebral injury. The fourth piece of evidence, the injury appraisal conclusion confirmed that Jiao Shangying’s injuries were minor.

Defendant Deng Junhai and defenders Fang Yi and Cao Yongzheng acknowledged the above evidence, but the evidence could not prove that the defendant was the murderer in this case.

"The fifth piece of evidence is the testimony of witness Deng Junhai: After the incident, Deng Junshan blocked the police. After that, Deng Junhai heard Jiao Shangying tell him that Deng Junshan was the murderer, but he was not allowed to report the case." said the female prosecutor.

"What objection does the defendant Deng Junshan have to the evidence?" the presiding judge asked.

"I have objections. I don't agree with what Deng Junhai said. He is talking nonsense." Deng Junshan said angrily.

"What does the defendant's defender have to say about the evidence?" The presiding judge looked at the defense table.

"The defender does not accept this evidence. Witness Deng Junhai heard others say that the defendant was the murderer and did not see it with his own eyes. This is a false accusation. Therefore, this evidence should not be used as evidence for conviction in this case." Fang Yi said.

Next, the inspector presented two testimonies from villagers. The content of the testimonies was similar to what Deng Junhai said. They both heard Jiao Shangying say that Deng Junshan was the murderer, but neither of them saw it with their own eyes.

As for the above-mentioned witness testimony, Fang Yi's reply was similar to his previous reply. It was based on false information and was not enough evidence.

"The eighth piece of evidence is the multiple statements made by the victim Jiao Shangying.

1. Statement after the incident: On the night of the incident, when she and Deng Lu were sleeping, someone opened the door and walked into the room, shined a flashlight on them, asked them to take out the money, and said to Deng Lu: Before Deng Lu had punished people when he was a village cadre, and he came to take revenge.

Then, the man held a wooden stick more than two feet long and as thick as a small wine glass in his right hand and hit Deng Lu on the head and body. Then he stabbed Deng Lu on the head several times with a knife more than ten centimeters long. After being injured, I groaned in pain in bed.

The man hit her on the forehead with a wooden stick again, and blood started to flow out, and the bones of her left forearm were also broken. The man rummaged through the house for a while, then tied her feet with ropes. He also dragged Deng Lu to the bed and tied her feet with ropes, and then left. Soon, Deng Lu died.

2. Four years after the incident, Jiao Shangying reported Deng Junshan as the murderer, stating: The murderer came to her and asked her where the money was. He sounded like her eldest son Deng Junshan. When the man pinched her neck, she could see his face clearly. That man was Deng Junshan.

3. After that, when Jiao Shangying was questioned again, she stated: When the murderer pinched her neck, she saw that the outline of the man’s face under his hat looked very much like her eldest son Deng Junshan. As soon as the man spoke, she knew it was Deng Junshan. Deng Lu and Deng Junshan had conflicts over the dispute over mountains and land, and Deng Junshan held a grudge. Deng Junshan is left-handed and usually works and eats with his left hand.

4. After identification by Jiao Shangying, it was confirmed that the wooden stick extracted from the crime scene was the tool used by Deng Junshan to kill Deng Lu and injure her. complete. "The female prosecutor said while giving evidence.

"What objection does the defendant Deng Junshan have to the evidence?" The presiding judge looked at the defendant.

"I don't agree, I haven't done it. She is talking nonsense. I didn't want to mention it originally, but since she threw shit on me, I have to mention it." Deng Junshan said loudly with red eyes.

Fang Yi and Cao Yongzheng were startled. What happened? They didn't even call "Mom" and changed it directly to "She". Is this case a case of annihilation of relatives out of justice or is there another hidden secret?

The presiding judge was also stunned. What's going on?

“During the autumn harvest last year, because I didn’t help her pick peanuts (peanuts) in the fields and I wasn’t willing to pay to repair my father Deng Lu’s grave, she felt that I had a bad conscience and didn’t take care of her, so she reported me.

But a slap can’t make a difference, why would I do this? There is a reason for that. You will know it when you go to the village and do a scan.

Last year, the jujube tree my brother divided had no fruit and there was no harvest. However, my jujube tree had many fruits and sold for a lot of money. So my brother encouraged Jiao Shangying to take back the jujube trees allocated to me and redistribute them.

We had a quarrel over this and almost got into a fight, so I didn't go to help Jiao Shangying when the fields were harvesting fruits, and later I didn't give her living expenses. For this reason, she held a grudge, framed me, and put me in jail..." Deng Junshan's eyes were full of angry tears.

Four chapters have been updated today. Please support me, book friends.