The Creator of the Second Dimension

This article originally originated from an answer to the question.

The respondent claimed to be a physics student at an aerospace academy.

At first, he just joked, saying that the special effects in the movie are pretty good, but the black hole doesn't seem too dark.

Totally clever.

But it was seen by some people.

So, a film critic from Peanut, whose ID is [Science Boundary], stood up.

He graduated from a good science and engineering university in Huaxia.

Of course, the major is finance.

His own occupation has nothing to do with astrophysics and the like, his usual hobby is photography, if shooting the starry sky is also related, then he does often deal with stars.

In college, he also accepted certain science and engineering subjects.

But after so many years, I have almost forgotten it.

After watching "Country Teacher", he remembered that Newton's second law is F=ma.

After holding back for two days, he couldn't find a suitable spray point.

There are some bits and pieces that can be written, but when written, it is probably the same as the guy who was sprayed to cancel the account. It is picking bones and nitpicking.

Accidentally, 【Science Boundary】saw that clever screenshot in the group.

He had an idea.

I bought another movie ticket and watched "Country Teacher" again.

This time, his main focus is on the wonders of the universe.

After watching [Boundary of Science], I walked out of the cinema refreshed, found a coffee shop, sat down and began to code with a notebook.

Soon, he revised this article [The Astronomical Fallacy in "The Country Teacher".

According to the usual practice, the article first praised "The Rural Teacher", which was full of voice and emotion, which made people cry.

This is a commonly used method, if you want to suppress it, you will first raise it.

The higher you lift, the more painful the fall.

Afterwards, the topic changed, [Science Boundaries] began to write about the wonders of the universe.

The first is the tiny black hole.

In the movie, black holes have two modes.

One is a mode that has not yet touched matter and is bound by a force field. In this case, there is a faint fluorescence around the black hole.

The other is that after touching the star, the entire star collapses and shines. In this mode, the black hole is surrounded by rotating blazing matter, shining brightly in the void.

[Science Boundary] I think there is a problem with this.

He checked the information (referring to encyclopedia) and pointed out that a black hole is a celestial body with a huge gravitational force, and even the light around it cannot escape, forming an event horizon, so people can't get any information from the black hole at all, and the black hole should also be pitch black of.

It's not the fluorescent one in the movie.

As for after touching the star, [Science Boundary] believes that although it should be similar to the movie at first, the star collapses and its matter is sucked into it.

But he feels that this kind of attraction is all-round, and the entire black hole should be surrounded by a mass of matter until it is completely absorbed.

But in the movie presentation, the black hole seems to have a halo, which is not symmetrical yet, and it seems to be similar from all angles.

[Science Boundary] thinks this may be because the special effects creators cut corners.

In addition, [Science Boundary] also interpreted scenes such as stellar transitions and supernova explosions, and found some imperfections he felt.

He finally said that "Country Teacher" is excellent as a blockbuster with special effects, but it is not enough to call it a science fiction movie. He also hopes that everyone will pay more attention to the development of science and not treat the images in the movie as real world.

This article was quickly posted on Peanut.com and also on his own Weibo.

Due to the high popularity of "Country Teacher", this article quickly spread a lot, and even caused great controversy on social media.

In the film and television section of the A2 forum, under the post of the forwarded article.

[Cat from the African Savannah]: I think what he said makes sense. Just like a vortex, the things around the black hole must be spinning towards the black hole. It is impossible to form a halo-like structure.

[Learning is too difficult]: And it is asymmetrical, one side is brighter and the other side is darker, which is too weird.

[Yin Shuai hides his name]: No one has ever seen a real black hole, so we can watch the movie as we make it up. Does it matter?

[Moonlight Candlelight]: One thing to say, the special effects of the movie are really good, this kind of texture has never been seen in previous movies, there is a little problem, I think it’s okay, it’s harmless.

[Mirror Flowers and Water Moon]: I majored in physics in college. After thinking about it, I feel that the black hole model in the movie is indeed not right. It may be because the special effects team must ensure the artistic sense of the movie. The real black hole is definitely not structured like this. .

[Gray rainy season]: I happened to be in the teaching and research section of the school, and used software to simulate a black hole. I feel that it is quite different from the movie.

[Magic Old Godmother]: If you want me to say, a black hole must be completely dark. I have already said in high school physics that even light cannot escape. If it is really shining like in the movie, wouldn’t it be casual? Then you can find black holes in the universe, why are you finding all of them now, and there are no photos.

[A dog that doesn’t eat fish]: In fact, it’s nonsense to use any force field to seal a black hole. It’s just a movie. There’s no need to think too much about it.

Everyone thinks about it carefully, only to realize that the images related to black holes in the movie seem to be somewhat contrary to common sense.

But for most people, this is a movie, not a science documentary.

They don't insist that the special effects produced by Phantom Media are exactly the same as reality, and there is nothing wrong with a little artistic processing.

If you really want to get entangled, those sci-fi movies in the past are all fake as hell.

What kind of beam saber confronts waves, shuttles between laser guns, and travels through time.

There are probably only a small group of extremists who are spouting wildly on this point.

After all, this is the only spray point.

[Science Boundary] Seeing that although my article was widely circulated, it didn't seem to have any substantial impact on the word-of-mouth of "Country Teacher", so I decided to write another one.

But before he could start writing, he saw a piece of news.

The Beishan Observatory in Ningjiang cooperated with five other observatories around the world to observe a black hole for four days, and it took two years to finally get the first photo of a black hole in human history.

The photo will be released globally on September 15th.

In an instant, whether it was "Rural Teacher" or the article in "Boundary of Science", they all became popular again.

People became curious.

What a real black hole really looks like.

Is the image display in "Country Teacher" that violates common sense correct, or is it just an artistic fabrication.

As the box office continues to rise, September 15th has also arrived.