The Director of Music Department

Don't look at the "Titanic" being a myth in the previous life. Indeed, looking at the history of film, it is difficult to find any movie that can compare with this movie.

Including Avatar!

Yes, "Titanic" is the most special and the most highly praised movie.

It can even be said that there is no one!

But many people say that the three views of this movie are actually seriously wrong!

Of course, this is the three views of this movie from the standpoint of Chinese people.

To say whether the Three Views are right or not, we should not only look at whether the morality conveyed by the film itself violates universal values, but also look at the background of the characters and the background of the times in it, just like Lu Xun commented on Dream of the Red Chamber. , "A Dream of Red Mansions, Confucians see "Yi", Taoists see obscenity, wits see lingering, revolutionaries see rowing, and message writers see the secrets of the palace!"

Extramarital affairs are not worth advocating, as they go against universal values, and public figures who cheat will be denounced by spectators, but there is a major premise for this, the premise of talking about marriage morality is that both parties are voluntary.

Pan Jinlian was given to Wu Dalang by her master. Her marriage with Wu Dalang was forcibly bound, so her controversy has always existed. Although Pan Jinlian is hateful, she also has a pitiful part of her helplessness, which is hateful and pitiful Exist at the same time, not contradictory.

Because Pan Jinlian was not voluntary from the beginning, she is pitiful, but at the same time her actions are also hateful.

Poor and hateful, not contradictory, it can only be said that life is like this!

Let's talk about the background of the relationship between Carl and Ruth in "Titanic": Carl needs to marry a noblewoman to improve his status, and Ruth's family needs to marry an upstart to maintain their status.

Is Ruth a poor girl who unilaterally depends on Carl? No, Ruth's surname is her most valuable thing. Money can buy many things, but it can't buy aristocratic blood, nor can it buy the real upper class represented by aristocrats, so their transaction is fair, no Carl was unilaterally squeezed by Ruth's family.

So what's in the deal? Ruth's mother signed a contract with Carl, and Ruth is the content of the contract.

Theoretically speaking, the buyer and the seller have agreed that if one party backs out and breaks the contract, it is indeed an act that should be condemned, but Ruth's situation is different. She is a living person, not a commodity, and she was forced to sign this contract. Some people say Her mother's moral abduction and naughty thoughts were nothing more than moral kidnapping, which could not do any real harm to her, but she still agreed, so this was her own decision.

Of course, this kind of background setting is also the reason why many people in China feel that the three views of this movie are not correct, but they are still acceptable.

Because, from the beginning to the end, the relationship between Ruth and Carl is not what you want.

The movie Titanic is not so much a love movie as it is Ruth’s personal growth. She agreed to her mother’s request at the beginning, but she didn’t express her true thoughts. She was awkward and confused. The answer to the question that you have to rely on Karl's support to survive, and in the end, Ruth lived well as a commoner, didn't she?

It's just that at the very beginning of the film, she didn't realize what she really wanted in the confused stage. What does this have to do with her personal ability? Indeed, Ruth's attitude at this meeting is not clear enough, but at this stage, she has not "derailed".

When did Ruth really start growing up? She thanked Jack, and the two chatted, knowing that there is another completely different way of life in this world. She saw Jack's paintings and admired his talent. She went to the third-class cabin with Jack and saw others what kind of life.

But at this time, she and Jack still haven't crossed the moral boundary.

After Ruth went back, Carl was violent, Ruth's mother warned her, Ruth said that she would work hard to support her mother (ready to get rid of Carl), but Ruth's mother refused, she forced Ruth to be with Carl, Ruth would not Wishing to disappoint her mother, she cut off contact with Jack.

At this stage, Ruth also did not "derail"!

In the third stage, Ruth saw the little girl strictly abide by the dining etiquette, and decided to resist this "marriage contract" that she had never made a decision under the painful inner struggle!

Ruth came back to find Jack, and left a note and the heart of the ocean to Carl before leaving (normal people know this means breaking up), and then played around with Jack, that is, after giving the note, Ruth finally It is a real "derailment"!

But in any case, in fact, what Ruth did was still following the Western views on marriage, values, and morals.

Try changing it to a Chinese girl!

Obviously, if Ruth is replaced by the face of Hua Guo, then if she really does those things, will the domestic audience accept it?

Wang Yifan's worry is not unfounded, but absolutely unacceptable.

In fact, this also involves a substitution problem.

When you watch "Titanic", the domestic audience will basically not substitute Ruth.

Because she is a foreign woman, everyone will naturally look at her according to the values ​​of foreigners.

So, she found Jack, "cheating" Jack, everyone can accept it.

Because didn't Ruth get involved with Jack from the beginning.

She got together with Jack only when she was desperate for Carl and her family.

But all of this is also based on her identity as a foreign girl, so everyone can accept it.

If you are from Huaguo, you will not be sprayed to death every minute.

Everyone will only say that no matter what the reason is, cheating is cheating!

As for Jack's approach, from a man's point of view, everyone likes it. After all, everyone loves beautiful women.

But from a moral point of view, Jack, knowing that Ruth has a fiancé, still went to tease her, this is really scum!

Therefore, Wang Yifan fiddled with it for a long time, and finally decided not to change it.

Some people may say why not change Jack into a Huaguo?

This is even scarier, why do you say that?

Because, there is a social class issue involved.

Why can everyone accept Chinese-Americans playing supporting roles in foreign movies, even if it's a side role.

But it's hard for everyone to accept the Chinese actors playing the big villains who do all kinds of evil?

Similarly, Jack, if he is from Huaguo, a situation will arise.

What will the people of the country think of it?

Oh, foreigners and girls are aristocrats, representatives of the rich, and Chinese people are poor?

Don't say this is just an example, the audience won't see it that way, and the media will definitely misinterpret it for you.

So, in the end, Wang Yifan simply didn't change it, and just followed the original version.

Everything for "Titanic" has been prepared, and Wang Yifan has officially turned his deaf ears to the outside world, and only focuses on making movies.

In fact, for Wang Yifan, it may be difficult for him to reproduce "Titanic" perfectly.

But for the truck driver, he actually has great convenience!