The Director of Music Department

For Chinese audiences, although the story of "Titanic" tells a Western story, it does not prevent them from liking the movie.

In other words, there is no sense of isolation.

In fact, to some extent, this is also due to the penetration of Hollywood movies over the years.

And Huaguo introduced a large number of movies and TV shows about Hollywood, etc., so that the audience will not have any deviation in understanding the Hollywood view of love.

Of course, the same is not that no one discredits "Titanic"!

But the angle of smearing is ingenious.

Hu Jie, a relatively well-known online film critic in Huaguo, wrote a film review about "Titanic", which won the unanimous affirmation of many Wang Yifan's black fans.

Hu Jie didn't attack this movie in other aspects, but attacked "Titanic" on the whole, in terms of the three views of the movie!

"I have different feelings about the recent "Titanic", which has been praised by many people as a classic. After watching it, I really don't understand how such a movie with extremely unfair three views has become a classic. made it?

First of all, Jack and Ruth, in my opinion, there is really no pressure to say that they are male mistresses and cheating women!

Let's take a look at the initial relationship between Jack, Rose, and Karl.

No matter how profiteering and narrow-minded Karl is, no matter how vain and rich Ruth's mother is, no matter how reluctant Ruth is to this marriage, in fact, she is indeed engaged to Karl, and their mother and daughter Carl provided her with a decent life. At the same time, Ruth also accepted the priceless heart of the ocean that Carl gave her, which is equivalent to her saying no to Carl to some extent, but The body is very honest", some people may say that Ruth is the product of the tragedy of that era, her marriage cannot be free, her love cannot be free, she is a victim.

But actually?

How can we conclude that Ruth is a victim in this relationship because Ruth does not have deep feelings for Carl, and Carl's feelings for Ruth are not as pure as Jack's?

Still the same sentence, if Ruth is really unwilling, then she can completely refuse. After boarding the boat, didn't she also think about committing suicide and fleeing marriage? Why are you afraid of refusing marriage when you are not afraid of death?

To put it bluntly, since she couldn't get rid of her mother at the beginning, couldn't live independently, and couldn't live without relying on Karl's marriage, shouldn't she be wronged and suffer? And how could it be that Karl didn't understand her?

And what about Jack?

In fact, he knew that Ruth had a fiancé. Under such circumstances, he still went to court, and Ruth had not broken up with Carl, but he still accepted Jack's pursuit. They got together quickly and dated wildly on the big ship, so, in my understanding, Ruth is more like the kind who enjoys the good living conditions provided by Karl but hypocritically wants to pursue herself It is a free love, and Jack is a typical little boy. Even if the movie uses his death to forcibly clear his name, he still cannot get rid of the fact that he has always been a third party! "

Hu Jie's comment, of course, has an ulterior motive.

However, it has found an outlet for some people.

No way, as many people love you, as many people are jealous of you.

Wang Yifan is indeed the number one director in China, but it doesn't mean that everyone recognizes him.

There are still quite a few people who just don't like him or are upset with him.

For this reason, some such as: "Little San and Green Tea have hooked up, can that be called love?"

"Is this the obscenity of a poor dick? Jack is a poor man. When he sees a rich daughter's beauty, he immediately becomes attracted to sex. Then, it hit it off, tsk tsk, this is also a classic, and the world is going down, and people's hearts are not old!"

Of course, though, everyone has their own opinion.

Hu Jie is not really something out of nothing.

But in the same way, if someone like Hu Jie forcibly smears, there will naturally be rebuttals.

A well-known Internet celebrity film critic directly and publicly refuted the argument that "three views are not correct" in April!

"Extramarital affairs are not worth advocating. They go against universal values. Public figures who cheat will be condemned by spectators, but there is a major premise for this. The premise of talking about marriage ethics is that both parties are willing.

Pan Jinlian was given to Wu Dalang by her master. Her marriage with Wu Dalang was forcibly bound, so her controversy has always existed. Although Pan Jinlian is hateful, she also has a pitiful part of her helplessness, which is hateful and pitiful Exist at the same time, not contradictory.

The general background of the relationship between Carl and Ruth on the Titanic: Carl needs to marry a noblewoman to improve his status, and Ruth's family needs to marry an upstart to maintain their status.

Is Ruth a poor girl who unilaterally depends on Carl? No, Ruth's surname is her most valuable thing. Money can buy many things, but it can't buy aristocratic blood, nor can it buy the real upper class represented by aristocrats, so their transaction is fair, no Carl was unilaterally squeezed by Ruth's family.

Therefore, it is a bit out of context to say that Ruth's good life is all due to Carl.

Of course, it is undeniable that Ruth and Carl do have a marriage contract, but let's analyze, did Ruth really cheat?

This movie is not so much a love movie as Ruth's personal growth. She agreed to her mother's request at the beginning, but she didn't express her true thoughts. She was awkward and confused. She said that she must rely on Carl The answer is that you can only live by supporting yourself. In the end, Ruth lived well with her status as a commoner?

It's just that at the very beginning of the film, she didn't realize what she really wanted in the confused stage. What does this have to do with her personal ability? It is true that Ruth's attitude at this meeting is not clear enough, but at this stage, she has not "derailed".

When did Ruth really start growing up? She thanked Jack, and the two chatted, knowing that there is another completely different way of life in this world. She saw Jack's paintings and admired his talent. She went to the third-class cabin with Jack and saw others what kind of life.

But at this time, she and Jack still haven't crossed the moral boundary.

After Ruth went back, Karl was violent, and Ruth's mother warned her that Ruth said that she would work hard to support her mother, which in itself meant that she was ready to get rid of Karl, but Ruth's mother refused, and she forced Ruth to stay with Karl. At the same time, Ruth did not want to disappoint her mother, so she broke off contact with Jack.

At this stage, Ruth also did not "derail"!

In the third stage, Ruth saw the little girl strictly abide by the dining etiquette, and decided to resist this "marriage contract" that she had never made a decision under the painful inner struggle!

Ruth came back to look for Jack, and left a note and the heart of the ocean for Carl before leaving. In fact, this is already very clear in itself. She is breaking up with Carl and drawing a clear line. It was after giving the note that Ruth was the real so-called "cheating"!

But at this stage, can this kind of cheating be considered cheating?

Even if it was a unilateral breakup, in fact, as far as Ruth was concerned, she had already broken up with Karl and was free. At this time, what did she do have anything to do with Karl?

Back to Jack.

 …

"