The wizard in Hogwarts is unscientific

What is the ghost missing?

This is not the first time Andy has thought about this issue.

Ghosts possess magical powers, but cannot use magic.

This is contrary to the idea of ​​"mind control magic".

Because ghosts have psychic powers, they are not a fixed program, but have feelings like living people.

So the ghost must be missing something important.

Andy thought for a moment, then finally shook his head and said, "Besides life, I really can't think of anything else the ghost lacks. Hmm...it can't be a body, right?"

"Yes!" Dumbledore nodded slightly.

"People who are under the Imperius Curse cannot control their bodies, but they can still use magic."

"Collins...do you think it's the soul that's using magic, or the body that's using magic?"

Ah this...?

Andy was stunned.

According to the characteristics of ghosts and the theory of the Imperius Curse... it turns out that our bodies are using magic?

But in this way, doesn’t it prove that the idea of ​​‘mind control magic’ is wrong?

But the existence of Obscurus and Andy's Patronus Charm can prove that this view is correct. The mind can not only control magic, it can also merge with magic.

Andy was a little dumbfounded.

Which part went wrong?

"Principal~"

Andy said helplessly: "Stop playing with me. If you have anything to say, just say it!"

Dumbledore shook his head slowly and smiled lightly: "This is a very interesting question, Collins. Believe me, if you hear the answer from my mouth, you will be very disappointed."

Andy: "..."

I don't know if I'm disappointed or not.

But I know I won't be able to sleep tonight.

Andy stopped talking.

At this point in the conversation, both parties actually had nothing to talk about.

If Dumbledore wants to kill Voldemort, he must train Harry. Because Harry is also Voldemort's Horcrux, only he can find the location of all Horcruxes.

As long as all the Horcruxes are destroyed, it will not be difficult for Voldemort...

All right! Even if all the Horcruxes were destroyed, it was not something ordinary wizards could do to deal with Voldemort.

In the last Wizarding War, if someone could defeat Voldemort once... even just once, Voldemort's deterrent power would not be as great as it is today.

——No one in the magic world dares to mention his name.

So it is imperative to train Harry, this is what Dumbledore must do.

And Andy also expressed his demands.

A pure wizard.

Andy can understand Dumbledore's approach, but that doesn't mean he has no complaints.

This is called stance, also called class enemy.

Just like ordinary people and the rich second generation.

Ordinary people can understand that the second generation of rich people enjoy the legacy of their parents - their wealth is the result of generations of hard work.

But understanding does not mean no complaints.

Once there is an opportunity, he will not hesitate to pull the opponent down and step on him a few times - and all of this has nothing to do with hatred.

When two people stand on different sides, understanding is the most useless emotion.

Andy waved his wand and released the silencing spell on Hermione.

The little witch glared at Andy angrily.

Hermione was extremely curious about the conversation between Andy and Dumbledore. But Hermione also knew in her heart that since Andy used the silencing spell, he would never tell her again.

"Professor Dumbledore, have you made a decision?" Hermione asked impatiently.

Rather than those secrets, she wanted to know how to solve the current crisis.

This is related to the safety of everyone at Hogwarts.

"certainly!"

Andy smiled and said: "The principal has already made a plan. We just need to go to class and live normally."

"Really?" Hermione looked at Andy suspiciously, and then at Dumbledore, feeling that something was wrong.

"of course it's true!"

Andy said: "Can the principal still lie to us?"

Having said this, Andy pulled out his chair and stood up, "Principal, Hermione and I are going back first, so I won't disturb your work."

After saying that, Andy glanced at Hermione, and the two left the principal's office together.

"I always feel like something is wrong..."

Hermione glanced at Andy and said, "Ever since you whispered to Professor Dumbledore, I felt that Professor Dumbledore was not normal."

"Of course, we told some secrets." Andy said.

"Okay!" Hermione stopped asking, "Do you want to go back to the dormitory?"

"It's still early, I want to go to the Room of Requirement to practice magic for a while." Andy said.

Hermione pondered for a moment, "Let's go together then!"

After the showdown with Dumbledore, Andy was in a much better mood, at least the pressure was not as great as before.

It is imperative to deal with Voldemort, and Andy has no intention of ruining Dumbledore's plan. If Dumbledore wants to train Harry, let him train him.

The plan succeeds and everyone is happy.

Even if he screws up, Andy can still transfer to another school!

It's not like the earth will stop spinning after leaving Hogwarts.

…

The magic practice room in the Room of Requirement.

Andy practiced a few magic tricks casually, gave Hermione a few pointers, and then sat cross-legged on the ground, recalling the question Dumbledore asked.

Ghost, what is missing?

"Don't ghosts have seven souls?" Andy had a strange look on his face.

If we use the Chinese theory to explain it, ghosts do not have seven souls.

There are many theories about the Seven Souls. Different eras and different schools of thought have different interpretations of the Seven Souls.

But one thing is the same.

The seven souls are unique to the physical body. After death, the seven souls also dissipate.

"Andy, what are you thinking about?"

Hermione looked at Andy in confusion, "Are you still thinking about the conversation with Professor Dumbledore?"

"without……"

Andy said: "I'm thinking about ghosts. What do ghosts lack compared to living people?"

"Ghosts don't have bodies!" Hermione said bluntly.

Andy rolled his eyes, isn't this nonsense.

"What else could it be?" Hermione asked.

Andy: "..."

Yes, what else could it be?

"Hermione, do you know the Imperius Curse?" Andy asked.

"The Imperius Curse is one of the three unforgivables. People who are hit by the Imperius Curse will be completely controlled by the caster, but strong willpower can resist the Imperius Curse..." Miss Know-It-All officially went online to share information about the Imperius Curse. Memorized it completely.

Andy asked with a distressed look on his face: "People who are under the Imperius Curse can't control their bodies, but they can still use magic. Why do you think this is?"

"Is the soul using magic, or is the body using magic?"

Andy had a feeling.

As long as you figure out the answer to this question, you can truly understand the role of the soul.