Scholar’s Advanced Technological System

For a scholar, rejection is not a rare thing.

Regardless of the size of the fame or the achievements made in the past, the journal has not been selected, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, which may result in the manuscript being hit back at a certain part of the review.

However, if the papers that have already been published are retracted, not everyone has a chance to meet them.

And don't discuss the water magazines that have broken the cans, and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For the papers that have already been printed, each retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly acknowledged that the papers that have been published have significant and irreparable errors.

So in general, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless there is extremely serious academic fraud or other things that are detrimental to the reputation of the scholar.

At that time, the Nobel Prize-winning academic fraud Xiaobao Qingzi incident in the biological world was sensational. Even though the entire academic community had already determined that her experimental results were p-p, it was still the Japanese Institute of Physics and Chemistry that could not stand the pressure, from Xiao Baofang. I got the written consent to withdraw the stap cell paper before I let Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.

Although the biological world and the field of integrated circuit design can not be compared horizontally, but iee, this report has ended the sudden withdrawal of the draft, it is quite unusual.

In short, after the first rejection of the manuscript in life, this time even the retraction was arranged, Lu Zhou felt that his academic career is probably no regrets.

However, this is the first time he has submitted a manuscript in the journal of ieee. This kind of journal is biased towards the journals in engineering electrical and electronic engineering. His professional field is still a little far away. Although there was a press release in the top journal of electrical engineering, I hope he can publish a paper on controllable fusion technology. However, considering that this technology involves a lot of things after all, it is finally euphemistically rejected.

I didn't expect my name to be rushed back for the first time at the top meeting of ieee, and it was still a ridiculous reason for "academic deception" and "falsification of experimental data."

After seeing the written retraction notice sent by ieee, Lu Zhou couldn’t help but feel a bit of emotion.

Heaven and earth conscience, is he the kind of person who will make jokes on experimental data?

He is not very clear about the influence of this international IC design and technology conference in the industry. What makes him feel is not because of the ridiculous reason, but because he has become more and more aware of these years, academic purity. And justice is more and more like a piece of paper that wipes the butt.

When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, they would not become like this...

"I heard that you were retracted?"

Sitting on the sofa of the dean of the Institute of Advanced Studies, when talking about this, Chen Yushan had a few smiles on her face.

Seeing her gloating scene, Lu Zhou sighed and said with a helpless expression: "I was retracted. Is it so happy?"

"What are you talking about, how can I gloat? It’s just a rare accident to see you eating, a bit of an accident."

Lu Zhou ridiculed himself and said: "If you can't talk about eating, you can't easily miss your face on ieee, and you are rushed back."

Chen Yushan: "Does they let you modify the paper and so on?"

"The retraction notice euphemistically mentions a sentence that allows me to modify the experimental data that seems to be somewhat "exaggerated". But they did not say where the exaggeration is, I can be sure that they did not repeat the test because there is no such condition."

Chen Yushan curiously asked: "So, are you going to change?"

"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled a little and said, "I don't want to change things."

In line with the reviewer's comments, it is a different matter to modify the obvious or easily misunderstood mistakes. This kind of ambiguity is even a false accusation. To be honest, he is not at all concerned.

Looking at the expression on Lu Zhou's face, Chen Yushan could not help but bend her lips.

"It’s a schoolmaster, this sentence is quite your style."

Lu Zhou said with a smile: "What does this have to do with Xueba."

"How come it doesn't matter? You think, when I used to read the book, I dared to talk to the teacher on the standard answer. Isn't it a school tyrant? If the **** is used, the teacher said that he is wrong, I am afraid he will recognize it. It is."

"Where is this and where?" Listening to this wonderful metaphor, Lu Zhou sighed and said, "And you are too exaggerated to make ieee a teacher. They are not qualified enough."

"It’s just a metaphor. It’s going to be with me.” Turned his eyes, Chen Yushan’s eyes turned, and suddenly a thought came out of his head, and he suddenly said, “Say, have you considered yourself? Create a journal?"

Lu Zhou nodded and said: "When I left yesterday, Warwick CEO and I talked about this issue."

In fact, it’s not just Warwick’s boss who told him about this problem, but his old friends in the domestic academic circles talked to him about it when he was chatting, but he was too troublesome and didn’t put it too much. In my heart.

After all, in his opinion, where the paper submission is secondary, the important one is the paper itself. An outstanding enough research result, even if it is hanging on arxiv, will certainly attract people's attention.

Only those studies that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.

But now, his ideas may still be somewhat idealistic.

Although the journal is just a platform for publishing academic results, it is still subject to some restrictions when using other people's microphones to speak. Even under normal circumstances, these restrictions are not reflected. The average person can't do anything to pull out the microphone power and slam the spokesperson to these disgusting and unproductive things, but it is clear that ieee has broken through the bottom line.

Perhaps, you really should consider it, do an academic journal and play it yourself.

"Wang Zhengfei and you said this question?" An unexpected look at Lu Zhou, Chen Yushan asked curiously, "What did he say?"

Lu Zhou thought about it and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are, after all, what we have come up with. It is not appropriate to hand it over to others for review. Now there is no research on the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. However, most research institutions and scholars still have a theoretical understanding of this gadget. It is too difficult for them to ask their opinions."

If thoughtfully nodded, Chen Yushan said: "I think so too... What do you mean?"

"I think he said something a bit."

When it came to a pause, Lu Zhou smiled and said, "I will look back and think about it. Our Jinling Institute of Higher Education has been established for so long. There are no journals in the hospital. It seems that it is really too bad. A little bit."

"I intend to set up a comprehensive journal in the name of the Institute of Advanced Studies... Of course, even if it is not for our senior research institutes, we can submit the manuscript, but we must seize it in our own hands."

Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"

"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. The editor-in-chief can be temporarily used by me. But if you want to create a journal, you still have to ask for it."

When he heard the words of Lu Zhou, Chen Yushan could not help but bend his lips.

"A little thing, give me peace of mind."

Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered a very important thing, so she asked.

"Right, I will ask, by the way, what is the name of this journal?"

It took about five minutes to seriously think about this problem, and Lu Zhou said, raising his head.

"Just called..."

"The future is good."